“Should I Become a Non-Commissioned Officer Instead of a Private?” What Makes Technical Non-Commissioned Officers Different? [“Military Insights” bykim kwanyong]
Lee Administration’s ‘Selective Conscription System’: In Reality, a System for Technology-Intensive Non-Commissioned Officers
Recruitment Channels for Non-Commissioned Officers—Including Civilian, Active-Duty, and Fixed-Term Positions—Are Already in Place
Recruitment Rate at 42% of Planned Quota… Compensation Is the Problem, Not the Entry Requirements
Without a separate compensation, position, and career plan, it may end up being just a “new name”
[Edaily Reporter kim kwanyong ] President Lee Jae-myung has touted the “selective enlistment system” as a key defense pledge since the presidential campaign and has repeatedly expressed his commitment to implementing it since taking office. In his speech commemorating Armed Forces Day on the 1st, he emphasized, “We will increase the number of technology-intensive non-commissioned officers through the selective enlistment system to shift the military’s personnel structure toward an officer-centered model.”
During this year’s parliamentary audit, the Ministry of National Defense reported that it would diversify the recruitment pathways for non-commissioned officers through the selective enlistment system, thereby establishing a stable foundation for securing personnel in cutting-edge science and technology fields. Previously, in its briefing on the 2027 defense budget proposal, the Ministry also stated that it had allocated funds to launch the selective enlistment system starting next year.
◇ An Existing System for Recruiting Non-Commissioned Officers
At first glance, the term “selective enlistment system” may seem like a major shift in the military service system. However, the plan outlined by the government so far involves maintaining the conscription system while allowing those subject to military service to choose between serving as regular soldiers or as technology-intensive non-commissioned officers. The plan is to select approximately 3,000 non-commissioned officers starting next year to serve in cutting-edge fields such as artificial intelligence (AI), drones, cybersecurity, and manned-unmanned integrated systems. Discussions are currently underway regarding a service term of either three or four years.
As the pool of conscripts shrinks due to population decline, the shift from a soldier-centric military structure to one centered on specialized personnel is inevitable. It is difficult for soldiers who have received only a few months of training to operate advanced weapon systems proficiently. Proficiency takes time to develop, and trained personnel must be utilized for an extended period. There are sufficient reasons behind the government’s decision to expand the ranks of technology-intensive non-commissioned officers.
Soldiers perform a ceremonial drill during the 78th Armed Forces Day ceremony held on the 1st at the Gyeryongdae airfield in South Chungcheong Province. (Photo: Yonhap News) The issue lies in the connotations of the term “volunteer military system.” It is a sensitive term intertwined with the abolition or reduction of conscription, the equity of military service obligations, and the burden of massive personnel costs. This is why there has been a long-standing debate within and outside the military, as well as in political circles, over whether to adopt a volunteer military system.
However, the selective volunteer system being promoted by the government is not intended to replace the conscription system. Universal conscription, which imposes military service obligations on all men, will remain in place. The core of the system is the selection of a portion of those subject to military service to serve as technically skilled non-commissioned officers (NCOs). According to the government’s explanation, this is a system that broadens the opportunities for soldiers and NCOs to choose their mode of service; it does not constitute a transition to a volunteer system in the conventional sense.
Moreover, the path for those subject to military service to become non-commissioned officers is already open. Civilians can apply to become non-commissioned officers, undergo training, and be commissioned as corporals, and active-duty soldiers can also apply to become non-commissioned officers during their service. Fixed-term non-commissioned officers are appointed as corporals after completing their active duty and serve an extended term ranging from 6 months to 4 years. This system is a rebranding of the former “paid volunteer soldier” program.
Of course, the selective conscription system and the term-based non-commissioned officer system are not entirely the same. The term-based non-commissioned officer system focuses on utilizing skilled soldiers who have completed their mandatory military service for a certain additional period. The government’s vision for technology-intensive non-commissioned officers involves selecting and training personnel in cutting-edge fields from the outset and allowing them to build expertise in their respective positions. Plans to link their civilian employment after discharge are also under consideration.
◇Political Nuances Must Be Set Aside to Focus on the Essence
However, based solely on the explanation that “one serves as a non-commissioned officer for several years instead of as an enlisted soldier,” it is difficult to discern the difference from existing civilian non-commissioned officers. It amounts to adding technical positions and employment support to the existing non-commissioned officer recruitment system while attaching the politically symbolic term “voluntary enlistment system.” Viewed objectively, the selective voluntary enlistment system is closer to a policy to expand the ranks of technical non-commissioned officers than a transformation of the military service system. It is inevitable that critics will argue the system was given a grand name to highlight a presidential campaign pledge, rather than reflecting its actual substance.
It is not that there is a shortage of applicants due to a lack of pathways to becoming a non-commissioned officer. The problem lies in the fact that young people are not choosing this path as a career. According to data disclosed during last year’s parliamentary audit, in 2024, only 3,400 of the 8,100 Army non-commissioned officer positions planned for recruitment were filled. This means the fill rate was only 42% of the planned quota.
The military is well aware of the causes. Low pay, repetitive on-call duties, assignments to remote locations, frequent relocations, and uncertainty regarding selection for long-term service have long been cited as factors driving young people away from junior officer positions. If the military recruits technical personnel but then assigns them the same duties as regular non-commissioned officers—including guard duty, on-call shifts, administrative tasks, and troop management—it will be difficult to compete with private companies for talent. Furthermore, if the expertise gained in the military is not recognized as qualifications or work experience in the civilian sector, employment support after discharge will remain nothing more than a slogan.
Newly commissioned noncommissioned officers pose for a commemorative photo during the graduation and commissioning ceremony for the 292nd class of Navy NCO candidates, held on August 14 at the Navy Education Command gymnasium in Jinhae-gu, Changwon, South Gyeongsang Province. (Photo: Yonhap News) The Army is also independently promoting its “Comprehensive NCO Development 4.0” vision. This plan aims to raise the average monthly pay for corporals to 3 million won by 2027, expand the selection of long-term service personnel, and identify NCO positions in cutting-edge fields. This overlaps significantly with the direction proposed by the selective conscription system. This underscores the need to clearly explain why a new system is necessary, separate from the proper implementation of existing NCO policies.
For the selective enlistment system to be recognized as a new system, the substance of the contract must differ from the label. It must specify which enlisted positions will be reduced and which technical positions will be converted to non-commissioned officer roles. It is also necessary to distinguish between general NCO career paths—focused on command and troop management—and those centered on technical proficiency. Separate allowances, training, national technical certifications, academic credit recognition, conversion to long-term service, and support for civilian employment must be included in the actual terms of service.
The government has stated that it will ensure military service leads to good jobs, education, and asset accumulation for young people. This is a step in the right direction. However, simply changing the name does not improve the quality of the jobs. If the problems of the existing non-commissioned officer system remain unaddressed and only technical positions and the label “voluntary enlistment system” are added, the selective voluntary enlistment system will be nothing more than a politically contrived neologism.
The question the government must answer is not merely “how many people will be recruited.” It must explain why the current non-commissioned officer system is insufficient and how the service and lives of the newly recruited, technology-focused non-commissioned officers will differ. These answers must be reflected in pay scales, rank structures, and career paths. While politicians coined the term, it is now up to the military to prove its viability as a system.
The price of Bitcoin plummeted to around $55,000 at one point during the week. This marked its lowest level in over two years. Having previously recorded six consecutive weeks of decline—a feat that h…
GS Retail(007070)has supported domestic small and medium-sized partner companies in Vietnam in expanding their overseas sales channels, resulting in export consultation deals totaling approximately $1…
A single video game generated $3.79 billion (approximately 5 trillion won) in sales worldwide on its first day of release. Pre-orders alone totaled 32.5 million copies before the official launch. As u…