“I’m Reporting My Husband for Tax Evasion Before Our Divorce”… Private Avengers and Paparazzi Lured by Reward Money
[The Republic of Whistleblower Rewards] (Part 2)
Whistleblower Rewards: Unlike the Lottery, No Taxes Are Deducted
Personal Conflicts, Such as Divorce and Layoffs, Can Sometimes Lead to Tax Evasion Tips
As Reports Increase, Verification Work Also Mounts… “Even If You Report It, It Won’t Be Processed Until Next Year”
Conflict Between Whistleblower and Authorities Over Reward Money
“Fostering a Society of Distrust… Unable to Sanction False or Malicious Reports”
[Sejong = E-Daily Reporter Kim Mi-Young ] A woman reported her husband—with whom she is currently in the midst of a divorce proceeding—to tax authorities on suspicion of tax evasion. The allegation was that he had not properly paid gift tax after inheriting real estate from his parents. An official in the tax industry stated, “There are cases where people report the other party’s alleged tax evasion in the course of personal conflicts.”
Although the government is actively working to revitalize the reward system—such as by establishing new rewards for reporting college entrance exam cheating, including “AI cheating”—critics point out that encouraging reporting does not necessarily yield only positive results. There are concerns that reports motivated by personal revenge, as well as false or malicious tips, are increasing rather than those made for the public good, and that administrative resources may be wasted in the process of sifting through them.
◇ Reports Are Rising, but a Closer Look at the Background Reveals a “Bitter” Reality
By establishing reward programs for reporting CSAT cheating and violations of the Price Stability Act (such as hoarding), as well as by removing the cap on rewards for reporting tax evasion, the government hopes to achieve a significant increase in the number of reports. The intent is to encourage active public participation—through rewards that, unlike lottery winnings, are not subject to income tax—to secure high-quality tips and thereby detect and prevent criminal activity.
[Edaily Reporter Kim Jeong-hoon] In fact, there are cases where tips have increased following an increase in reward limits. After the National Tax Service raised the reward limit for tax evasion tips from 3 billion won to 4 billion won in 2018, both the number of reports received and the number of cases leading to tax assessments rose. According to the National Assembly Budget Office on the 19th, the number of tax evasion tip-offs received rose by 30 percent, from 15,628 in 2017 to 20,319 in 2018, and further increased by 10.5 percent year-over-year to 22,444 in 2019. The number of cases leading to tax assessments also rose from 3,546 in 2017 to 4,035 in 2018 and 4,416 in 2019, representing increases of 13.8% and 9.4%, respectively. The total amount of rewards paid also increased from 11.5 billion won in 2017 to 15.0 billion won in 2019.
However, tax industry insiders generally agree that when examining the circumstances behind these reports, there are quite a few cases that are far removed from “public interest.” They note that a significant number of tax evasion reports stem from personal conflicts or a desire for retaliation.
Another tax industry official stated, “I’ve heard of a case where someone meticulously copied and stored documents alleging tax evasion at their workplace, and after being fired, brought 10 years’ worth of records to the tax authorities, urging them to ‘process this quickly before the statute of limitations expires.’”
Given these entangled conflicts of interest and responsibilities, some are questioning whether it is appropriate to pay reward money. Lee Jong-wook, a lawmaker from the People Power Party, asked during a meeting of the Tax Subcommittee of the National Assembly’s Finance, Economy, and Planning Committee on the 2nd, “There is a possibility that most of the people who file reports are accomplices to some extent. If they flee abroad after filing a report and walk away with tens of billions of won, would the public find that acceptable?”
There are also signs of people acting as professional “reward hunters” solely for financial gain. On online forums, it is not difficult to find posts recommending various types of reporting—such as failure to issue cash receipts or traffic violations—as a side job, claiming, “We offer paid training on how to file reports for government-administered rewards.” There are also posts from victims of companies promoting “reward reporting training,” with one user complaining, “They said they’d teach me how to file reports, but then they forced me to buy a camera.”
An official in the education sector remarked, “Couldn’t even students who are too immature to know better collude to commit cheating on the College Scholastic Ability Test just for the money and then report it themselves?” adding, “Becoming blinded by the reward money alone could actually have a negative effect.”
◇ Conflict with Authorities Over Reward Money… Administrative Resources Wasted on False Reports
Another issue is whether there are sufficient administrative resources to handle the reports. This is because a system intended to supplement the government’s oversight functions through citizen reports could actually increase the administrative burden. If the number of reports increases while the number of staff and processing capacity remain the same, the speed of handling tips will inevitably slow down.
In the case of the National Tax Service, the number of tax evasion reports processed last year reached 30,345, a 23% increase from the previous year. This figure rose significantly as 5,699 reports received the previous year but not yet processed were carried over. An official from the National Tax Service explained, “When a report comes in, it takes time to verify the facts by checking the financial transaction records of the suspect and those around them, so reports pile up and fall behind.”
Conflicts between tipsters and authorities over the payment of rewards also continue.
In 2024, the National Tax Service processed 18,888 tax evasion tips and paid rewards for 310 of them. In simple terms, the number of cases for which rewards were paid amounts to only about 1.6% of the total cases processed. Another industry official noted, “Whistleblowers press us, asking, ‘Why aren’t you processing this quickly?’ while those reported protest, asking, ‘Who made the tip-off?’” The official added, “If we decide not to pay a reward, they push back, asking, ‘Why aren’t you giving the reward?’ making the work very demanding.”
Cases are also continuing to be filed with the Tax Tribunal, with claimants seeking adjudication after having their reward claims denied or receiving insufficient payments. From 2020 through November of this year, there were more than 160 decisions on such appeals, of which only 23 upheld the claimants’ arguments. In a significant number of cases, the claimants failed to provide crucial evidence or did not meet the requirements for a reward because the amount of evaded taxes was less than 50 million won. In April of this year, there was a case where a whistleblower identified a specific property in Gangnam, Seoul, as subject to comprehensive aggregate taxation but submitted only building and land registers—which are easily accessible to anyone—and Street View data. When the Gangnam District Office refused to pay the tax collection reward, the whistleblower filed an appeal, which was subsequently dismissed.
Above all, there is significant criticism that the government is fostering mistrust among citizens. Hong Ki-yong, a professor emeritus at Incheon National University, pointed out, “There is no way to sanction false or malicious reports, and this undermines the climate of trust in society,” adding, “The government is attempting to resolve issues that require improvements to policies and systems by encouraging reporting.”
BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, forecasts additional growth opportunities in the Bitcoin and cryptocurrency investment product markets. However, the firm predicts that tokenization will …
Mezzion Pharma Co., Ltd.(140410)has overturned a rejection decision that had been blocking the registration of a U.S. patent for the use of Udenafil in the treatment of liver disease. The company plan…
(Graphic: ChatGPT)
Celltrion(068270)’s European subsidiaries have secured supply contracts one after another in procurement tenders conducted by local hospitals and pharmaceutical purchasing organ…