[Market Insight] KoreaZinc Dispute: A Long-Drawn-Out Battle in Court… Conflicting Rulings Complicate the Calculations
MBK and Youngpoong Win First-Instance Ruling in Lawsuit to Overturn AGM Resolution
Resolution to Appoint Directors and Audit Committee Members Revoked… Corporate Governance Uncertainty
Lawsuit Seeking to Invalidate New Share Issuance Reversed in KoreaZinc’s Appeal
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] As the management control dispute surrounding KoreaZinc(010130)drags on for over two years, the legal battle between the two sides is also becoming protracted. On the 12th, the MBK Partners–Youngpoong consortium won a lawsuit seeking to overturn a shareholders’ meeting resolution, and on the 13th, KoreaZinc prevailed in the appellate trial of a lawsuit challenging the validity of a new share issuance, overturning the first-instance ruling. As the two sides experience mixed fortunes in key lawsuits, attention is now focused on the impact these recent rulings will have on KoreaZinc’s board composition and corporate governance.
“Restricting Voting Rights of Cross-Shareholders for the Purpose of Defending Management Control Is Illegal”
According to legal and investment banking (IB) industry sources on the 16th, the Seoul Central District Court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs on the 12th in a lawsuit filed by MBK and Youngpoong against KoreaZinc seeking to annul a shareholders’ meeting resolution. This ruling orders the annulment of key resolutions—including amendments to the articles of incorporation and the appointment of directors and audit committee members—that were passed at KoreaZinc’s regular shareholders’ meeting in March 2025 while restricting the voting rights of its largest shareholder, Youngpoong(000670).
The central issue in this lawsuit was the legality of the measures taken by KoreaZinc to restrict Youngpoong’s voting rights based on a cross-shareholding relationship formed through the use of overseas affiliates. In January of last year, ahead of an extraordinary general meeting, KoreaZinc established a cross-shareholding relationship by acquiring a stake in Youngpoong through its Australian subsidiary, Sun Metal Corporation (SMC). Subsequently, ahead of the regular general meeting in March, KoreaZinc restructured its shareholding by distributing the Youngpoong shares held by SMC as an in-kind dividend to its Australian subsidiary, Sun Metal Holdings (SMH).
Based on this, KoreaZinc applied the provisions of the Commercial Act restricting voting rights in cross-shareholding arrangements to limit Youngpoong’s exercise of voting rights. In contrast, MBK and Youngpoong filed a lawsuit, arguing that it was unfair to deprive the largest shareholder of voting rights by utilizing a cross-shareholding structure artificially created to defend management control.
In the first-instance ruling, the court held that it is not permissible to restrict the voting rights of existing shareholders by applying regulations on cross-shareholdings for the purpose of defending management control. This effectively acknowledged the illegality of the voting rights restrictions that MBK and Youngpoong had been arguing against.
Board Composition Remains a Variable… Legal Battle Inevitable Until Final Appeal
This first-instance ruling is expected to weigh on KoreaZinc’s current corporate governance structure. This is because the amendments to the articles of incorporation—such as setting a cap on the number of directors—and the resolutions to appoint directors and audit committee members, which were approved at the annual general meeting at the time, are now subject to review, potentially reigniting controversy over the legality of the board’s composition. If the ruling becomes final, further legal disputes may arise regarding not only the status of the directors and audit committee members appointed at that time but also the impact on board operations and general meeting resolutions.
In particular, from the perspective of KoreaZinc’s management—for whom the stability of the board’s composition is crucial—the increased uncertainty surrounding the validity of the general shareholders’ meeting resolutions could prove burdensome. There is also a possibility that MBK and Youngpoong could use this ruling as grounds to once again raise questions regarding the legitimacy of the corporate governance restructuring and the composition of the board.
However, a different conclusion was reached in a previous preliminary injunction case. The application for a preliminary injunction regarding the exercise of voting rights, filed by MBK and Youngpoong ahead of the regular shareholders’ meeting last March, was dismissed, and that decision was finalized by the Supreme Court in April of this year. In effect, different rulings were issued in the preliminary injunction and the main lawsuit concerning the same regular shareholders’ meeting. KoreaZinc has stated that it will immediately appeal this first-instance ruling, arguing that it conflicts with existing Supreme Court precedents and the ruling in the preliminary injunction case.
Lawsuit to Invalidate New Share Issuance: First-Instance Ruling Overturned, KoreaZinc Wins
On the other hand, on the 13th, KoreaZinc successfully mounted a counterattack by winning the appeal in the lawsuit seeking to invalidate the new share issuance. The Seoul High Court overturned the first-instance ruling—which had found in favor of the plaintiff in the lawsuit filed by Youngpoong seeking a declaration of invalidity of the new share issuance—and dismissed the claim. The court determined that the third-party private placement conducted by KoreaZinc in August 2023 targeting HMG Global, an overseas affiliate of the HyundaiMotor Group, was carried out within the scope necessary for business purposes.
In the first-instance ruling last June, the court had sided with Youngpoong, finding that KoreaZinc had violated its articles of incorporation, but this conclusion was overturned on appeal. With this ruling, KoreaZinc has secured recognition of the validity of the capital increase targeting the HyundaiMotor Group, thereby partially alleviating the legal burden surrounding its existing shareholding structure. However, since Youngpoong may still file a further appeal, it is expected to take some time before a final legal conclusion is reached.
As the legal battle between the two sides continues, uncertainty surrounding the management control dispute is expected to persist for the time being. In particular, since the lawsuit seeking to annul the resolution of the regular general shareholders’ meeting is directly linked to the composition of KoreaZinc’s board of directors, the appellate court’s ruling is expected to be a key factor moving forward.
LG Innotek has developed an ultra-compact communication module for smart home cameras that integrates Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and Thread into a single unit. As the company expands its technological capabili…
OTOKI has succeeded in increasing its revenue, driven by strong sales of instant noodles and sauces and rapid overseas growth, despite deteriorating profitability in the domestic market.Ottogi(007310)…
MEDIPOST CO., LTD.(078160)continued its growth trend year-over-year, posting consolidated revenue of 57.5 billion won through the third quarter of this year. “Cartistem,” a stem cell therapy for knee …