Issues & Trends

Belated Response to the Joongang Group Crisis... Han Shin Rating's Credibility Ranks 'Last'

[37th Credit Rating Expert Survey] ③ Credit Rating Agency Rankings Determined by How They Handled Defaults Han Shin Rating Plummets from Joint First Place to Last Place Korea Ratings Takes Sole Lead; NICE Ratings Rises to Second Place

Hur Jieun
2026-11-16 20:44:04
[Edaily Marketin, Reporter Hur Jieun ] While the trust ratings of domestic credit rating agencies have remained in the 4-point range for four consecutive years, Korea Credit Rating—which tied for first place last year—has fallen to last place among the three agencies. Korea Corporate Rating took sole first place, followed by NICE Credit Rating in second. How individual credit rating agencies responded to the JR Global REIT and JoongAng Group incidents is cited as the main factor behind the gap in trust ratings.

Trust Scores in the 4s, but… Response to Defaults Determined the Rankings

The 197 valid respondents who participated in the 37th SRE survey gave an average score of 4.00 out of 5 when asked about their confidence in the credit ratings of the three major credit rating agencies. Although this was 0.02 points lower than the all-time high recorded in the previous survey (4.02 points), it marked the fourth consecutive year that the score has remained in the 4-point range since the 34th survey (4.01 points). One SRE advisory committee member stated, “Maintaining a score in the 4-point range means the credit rating system is still functioning well.”

However, some view this high level of trust not entirely positively. Another advisory committee member pointed out, “High trust ratings themselves can send the wrong signal to credit rating agencies,” noting that in a system where satisfaction rises as ratings increase, it becomes difficult to downgrade ratings first.

By agency, Korea Ratings took sole first place with 3.78 points, followed by NICE Ratings (3.75 points) and Korea Credit Rating (3.74 points). Korea Credit Rating’s decline in score was particularly notable. Han Shin Pyeong’s credibility score fell by 0.09 points from 3.83 last year. After ranking at the bottom for two consecutive years starting in 2022 due to a delayed response during the Legoland crisis, the agency had been on a recovery trend for the past two years, but has now slipped back to last place.

Critics point out that the credit risk warning issued for SLL Joongang, an affiliate of the Joongang Group, came later than those issued by its competitors. While Korea Ratings changed its rating outlook to “negative” in June of last year, Han Shin Rating did not take the same action until April of this year—approximately nine and a half months later. Subsequently, it downgraded the credit rating from BBB- on June 9 to B on June 15, a five-notch downgrade in just six days.

Korea Ratings also faced criticism for being “too slow to react” after maintaining an investment-grade rating until just before default. In the case of the JR Global REITs crisis, Korea Ratings maintained the same rating until mid-April. Han Shin Rating had previously changed its rating outlook to “negative” in early March. Although Han Ki-pyeong’s score dropped by 0.05 points—its lowest since the 30th evaluation—it retained its ranking by securing the sole top spot for the second consecutive year. An SRE advisory committee member pointed out, “Both Joongang Group and JR were carrying a ‘stable’ outlook before suddenly collapsing,” adding, “There is widespread dissatisfaction regarding whether [credit rating agencies] actually have the ability to predict defaults.”

[Edaily Reporter Kim Il-hwan]

Outlook Satisfaction at 5-Year High… “Upgrade Pace Should Be Slowed”

Satisfaction with rating outlooks rose for the second consecutive year to 3.62 points, the highest level since the 32nd survey (3.65 points). The trigger score—which defines the conditions for rating changes—fell by 0.04 points to 3.79. Analysts attribute this to the faster pace of upgrades, which has shortened the duration that ratings remain under a specific outlook. However, some have pointed out that while downgrades still take about one to one and a half years, upgrades are implemented immediately once a rating approaches the trigger threshold. One advisory committee member stated, “Credit rating agencies frequently move the goalposts,” adding, “When indicators deteriorate, they change their evaluation methods and then adjust the trigger criteria generously to accommodate the resulting figures.”

This year, the ratio of credit rating upgrades to downgrades among the three credit rating agencies jumped from 1.07 at the end of September last year to 2.77 at the end of September this year. This means that the number of companies whose credit ratings were upgraded is nearly three times that of companies whose ratings were downgraded. Excluding defaults, the ratio is 3.30. Of the 197 respondents, 132 (67.0%) answered that “the current pace of rating adjustments is appropriate,” though this figure is 10 percentage points lower than in the previous survey (77%). Forty-two respondents (21.3%) said the “pace of upgrades should be slowed,” and among the 62 credit analysts (CA), 18 (29.0%) gave this response.

One advisory committee member stated, “For sectors with negative outlooks, such as petrochemicals, downgrades have been delayed due to the Middle East boom, while sectors with strong performance have been upgraded quickly—this asymmetry has caused the ratio to rise significantly,” adding, “The issue of credit rating agencies’ predictive accuracy needs to be addressed.” Nevertheless, regarding the fact that the majority viewed the current level as appropriate, the member explained, “Since ratings are the only thing they can trust, they have evaluated the upgrade-to-downgrade ratio positively.”

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

With the Possibility of a U.S. 'Big Step'… 'Warning Signs' for Corporate Credit Risk

With speculation mounting that the U.S. Federal Reserve (Fed) may take a “big step” (a 0.5 percentage point hike in the benchmark interest rate) this coming December, concerns are growing that prolong…
2026-11-16 20:48:03

Corporation

OTOKI’s 3Q Operating Profit Falls 34.5%, but… Overseas Sales Show Double-Digit Growth

OTOKI has succeeded in increasing its revenue, driven by strong sales of instant noodles and sauces and rapid overseas growth, despite deteriorating profitability in the domestic market.Ottogi(007310)…
2026-11-16 18:07:59

IT·Science

Rainbow Robotics Reports 3Q Revenue of 13.9 Billion Won… Loss Widens

Rainbow Robotics(277810)reported a widening net loss in the third quarter of this year despite revenue growth. While sales to its largest shareholder, SamsungElectronics, increased, the proportion of …
2026-11-16 18:49:08