[37th SRE][Cover] A Government Focused Solely on Stocks… The Bond Market Left Behind
[37th SRE]
Policy Efforts Focused on Boosting the Stock Market… Bond Market Left Behind
66.5% of Experts Say “Stock Market Policies Have a Negative Impact on Bond Supply and Demand”
40.1%: “The Contraction in the Corporate Bond Market Could Lead to Structural Problems”
“Expanding the breadth and depth of the capital market is the right approach”
[Edaily Marketin LEE GEON-EOM Reporter] This year, all eyes in the capital markets have been fixed on the stock market. The government has made revitalizing the stock market its top policy priority, and the National Pension Service has reduced its allocation to domestic bonds while increasing its allocation to domestic stocks. Securities firms, too, are required to allocate a certain percentage of the funds they raise—such as through commercial paper—to venture capital.
Meanwhile, the bond market has been pushed aside from the policy spotlight. As the flow of funds into corporate bonds has decreased, the market’s supply-and-demand foundation has weakened. Concerns are emerging in the market that this contraction may not be merely a temporary phenomenon but could solidify into a structural problem. Calls are growing for sustainable support measures—not one-off bailouts pulled out during every crisis—to broaden the bond market’s supply-and-demand foundation.
Policies
Focused on Boosting the Stock Market… ‘Negative’ for Bond Supply and Demand
In the
bond
market, the prevailing view is that the government’s policies to revitalize the stock market have led to the contraction of the corporate bond market. The National Pension Service is the best example of this. At its fifth meeting this year, the National Pension Service’s Fund Management Committee approved the “2027–2031 Medium-Term Asset Allocation Plan,” raising the target allocation for domestic stocks from 14.9% to 20.8% and lowering the target allocation for domestic bonds by 1.8 percentage points, from 24.9% to 23.1%. The plan is to reduce the domestic bond allocation by a further 1.3 percentage points to 21.8% next year. Analysts note that, since securities firms are also required to allocate a certain percentage of funds raised through instruments such as commercial paper to venture capital, the amount of capital flowing into corporate bonds has decreased. In fact, in the 37th Edaily Credit Rating Expert Survey (SRE: Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily), 131 out of 197 bond market experts (66.5%) responded that the government’s stock market revitalization policies had a negative impact on the supply and demand of funds in the domestic bond market. Among them, 43 respondents (21.8%) answered “very much so.” In contrast, only 21 respondents (10.7%) believed there was no negative impact. The average score was 3.75 out of 5, indicating a clear perception across the market that stock market policies have worsened bond supply and demand.
Looking at the details, 45 out of 62 credit analysts (CA) (72.6%) reported a negative impact, which was 6.1 percentage points higher than the overall average. Among non-credit analysts (non-CA), 86 out of 135 (63.7%) shared this view, and 62 out of 97 (63.9%) bond managers who directly manage funds also agreed that there was a negative impact.
SRE advisory board members also cited the government’s bias toward the stock market as a problem. One advisory board member pointed out that the government is effectively treating the KOSPI 5,000 and 6,000 levels as key performance indicators (KPIs). “The government is solely interested in fostering the venture capital and equity markets, while no one is paying any attention to the bond market,” he said. “Although it has occasionally implemented measures to revitalize the market—such as high-yield funds—and provided tax incentives in the past, it has lost interest even in those now.”
Another advisory committee member explained that since around 2016, as venture capital flowing into securities firms has increased by 15% annually, the government has gained a means to expand direct financing without injecting public funds, thereby reducing the incentive to revitalize the corporate bond market. He relayed, “I’ve even heard from the Ministry of Economy and Finance that they won’t take action because it would involve tax revenue amid the controversy over tax cuts for the wealthy.”
Concerns of a ‘Structural Problem’ Beyond a Temporary Slowdown
The problem is that the contraction of the corporate bond market may not be merely a temporary phenomenon. In the 37th SRE survey, 79 out of 197 respondents (40.1%) answered that the recent contraction in the corporate bond market is likely to lead to structural problems. Sixty-five respondents (33%) disagreed, while 53 (26.9%) remained neutral. The average score was 3.12, indicating that the view that it could lead to structural problems was slightly predominant.
By job category, 26 out of 62 CAs (41.9%) and 53 out of 135 non-CAs (39.3%) placed greater weight on the possibility of structural problems arising. Among bond managers, 34 out of 97 (35.1%) held this view, which was 5 percentage points lower than the overall average. When asked to select up to two issues of greatest concern should market contraction and polarization continue, “increased corporate financing costs and credit risk” received the most votes, with 107 out of 348 total votes (30.7%). Among respondents, 54.3% of the 197 surveyed cited this issue.
This was followed by “reduced market access for corporate bonds issued by non-investment-grade companies rated A or lower,” which received 64 votes (18.4%), while “a contraction in market size and investor base due to a decline in corporate bond issuance” and “increased reliance on alternative funding sources such as commercial paper (CP), short-term bonds, and bank loans” each received 62 votes (17.8%). “Weakening of market liquidity and price discovery functions due to a concentration on high-quality bonds” also received 52 votes (14.9%). This result is interpreted as reflecting concerns that the more companies pushed out of the corporate bond market rely on short-term instruments such as commercial paper (CP) or short-term bonds, the greater their refinancing burden becomes, which in turn could lead to an increase in credit risk.
“Expanding the breadth and depth of the capital market is the right approach”
It has been pointed out that the government’s reluctance to revitalize the corporate bond market stems from the perception that existing support measures are sufficient. The argument is that, since separate mechanisms exist to prevent corporate insolvency, the government does not feel the need to actively expand the corporate bond market. One advisory committee member explained, “From the government’s perspective, the goal is to save non-investment-grade companies or prevent them from failing, not to have them raise funds through the corporate bond market.” He added, “Given the abundance of support measures—such as the Bond Market Stabilization Fund, win-win finance initiatives, and the authorization of securities firms’ Integrated Investment Accounts (IMA)—the government believes it is fulfilling its role adequately.”
There is also criticism that the bailout-focused responses, which recur every time a crisis strikes, actually increase market uncertainty. Another advisory committee member pointed out, “Calling on the Bond Market Stabilization Fund at every opportunity has become a chronic habit, making restructuring difficult and causing credit rating agencies to become desensitized to liquidity risks, assuming the government will help anyway.” He went on to emphasize, “It’s possible that market uncertainty has increased because companies destined for bankruptcy have been allowed to remain in the market,” adding, “We need to carry out restructuring by cutting what needs to be cut and weeding out what needs to be weeded out.”
The policy direction sought by bond market experts is also focused on improving supply-and-demand dynamics rather than one-time support. In the 37th SRE, when asked to select the top policies (up to two) that should be prioritized to revitalize the corporate bond market, “Alleviating market supply-and-demand pressures caused by the issuance of ultra-high-grade bonds, such as public and bank bonds” ranked first with 77 votes (22.6%) out of a total of 340 votes. “Revitalizing the corporate bond secondary market and enhancing liquidity” followed closely behind with 76 votes (22.4%), while “Expanding the investment base for corporate bonds among institutional investors, such as pension funds and insurance companies” took third place with 67 votes (19.7%). In contrast, “Strengthening market stabilization measures for corporate bonds and commercial paper, such as the Bond Market Stabilization Fund” received 37 votes (10.9%), the fewest votes among the options excluding “Other.” “Expanding incentives for investment in non-investment-grade corporate bonds, such as tax benefits and the revitalization of high-yield funds” (40 votes, 11.8%) and “Improving corporate bond issuance, disclosure, and book-building systems” (39 votes, 11.5%) also ranked near the bottom. This reflects the view that structural support—which broadens market supply and demand conditions and expands the investor base—is needed rather than one-off support measures deployed only during crises.
By job category, 28.5% (47 votes) of the votes cast by bond managers were concentrated on “alleviating supply-demand pressures for investment-grade bonds,” which was 5.9 percentage points higher than the overall average. This indicates that those on the front lines are feeling the supply-demand pressures resulting from investment-grade bond issuances more acutely. Among CA respondents, 24.8% (27 votes) cited “expanding the institutional investor base,” which was 5.1 percentage points higher than the overall average.
Market participants believe that the corporate bond market can only regain its proper function if the government examines both the supply-demand dynamics and the distribution infrastructure of the bond market, rather than focusing its policy efforts solely on the stock market. An SRE advisory committee member emphasized, “Expanding the breadth and depth of the capital market itself is the proper approach, rather than relying on preferential or distorted micro-policies.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
This year, all eyes in the capital markets have been fixed on the stock market. The government has made revitalizing the stock market its top policy priority, and the National Pension Service has redu…
Mezzion Pharma Co., Ltd.(140410)has taken a calculated risk by selling two Australian patents for udenafil for 5.4 billion won, thereby removing itself from the list of stocks subject to investment ca…
Rainbow Robotics(277810)reported a widening net loss in the third quarter of this year despite revenue growth. While sales to its largest shareholder, SamsungElectronics, increased, the proportion of …