[37th SRE][Survey] NICE Rating Ranks No. 1 in Seminars for Third Consecutive Year… Hanshin Rating Leads in Research Reports
[37th SRE]
Korea Ratings, Satisfaction with Rating Reports Rises from 3rd to 1st Place
NICE Ratings and Han Shin Ratings Secure Top-3 Rankings in Best Report
“Credit Rating Agencies Expand Coverage… Impressive Rapid Response”
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] Korea Ratings took first place in both rating reliability and satisfaction with rating reports at the 37th SRE. Korea Ratings was also named the credit rating agency whose reports are used most frequently. In contrast, Hanshin Ratings, which had ranked first in both rating reliability and satisfaction with rating reports at the 36th SRE, managed to secure first place only in the satisfaction evaluation for research reports this year, resulting in a somewhat disappointing performance. Na Credit Rating maintained its first-place ranking in seminar satisfaction for the third consecutive year.
Han Ki-pyeong Ranks First in Rating Reports… Han Shin-pyeong Leads in Research Reports
In the research report satisfaction category, Han Shin Pyeong took first place with 62 votes (31.5%). Having ranked second for two consecutive years since 2024—trailing Na Shin Pyeong—Han Shin Pyeong successfully reclaimed the top spot after three years. Na Shin Pyeong ranked second with 56 votes (28.4%). Meanwhile, Han Ki-pyeong received only 33 votes (16.8%) in this year’s research report satisfaction category, marking a significant drop compared to last year (56 votes). As the quality of research reports from the three credit rating agencies has become more uniformly high, 46 votes (23.4%) were cast for the response “No difference,” which was more than the number of votes Han Ki-pyeong received.
By job category, credit analysts (CA) gave the most votes to Korea Ratings (22 votes, 35.5%). In contrast, non-CA staff gave the most votes to Han Shin Rating (43 votes, 31.9%), thereby raising the overall average. An SRE advisory committee member explained, “Han Shin Pyeong published many excellent research reports this year,” adding, “The private credit seminar Han Shin Pyeong co-hosted with Moody’s also drew attention for addressing global topics.”
In contrast, Han Ki-pyeong received consistent praise in the rating report category. When asked which credit rating agency’s rating reports (including summaries) they use most frequently, Han Ki-pyeong secured an overwhelming first place with 68 votes (34.5%). NICE and Han Shin-pyeong recorded 59 votes (29.9%) and 51 votes (25.9%), respectively. Han Ki-pyeong also ranked first among the three agencies in the rating report satisfaction survey, scoring 3.85 points.
In terms of preference by job category, both CA and non-CA professionals gave high marks to HanKiPyeong. HanKiPyeong, which has traditionally enjoyed the support of the CA group, received a high score of 4.02 from the CA group in this year’s rating report satisfaction survey as well. The non-CA group also gave Han Ki-pyeong a score of 3.77, a higher rating than Na Shin-pyeong (3.73) and Han Shin-pyeong (3.72). However, in a survey asking which agency’s evaluation reports are used most frequently, CA respondents cast 20 votes for Na Credit Rating and 19 for Han Credit Rating, while among non-CA respondents, Han Credit Rating received 49 votes and Na Credit Rating 39, showing a divergence in preferences by occupational group. Han Shin Rating received the fewest votes from both CA (17 votes) and non-CA (34 votes) respondents.
An SRE advisory committee member explained, “These days, a rapid response when an issue arises has become the norm,” adding, “Credit rating agencies have expanded their coverage to the point where they are forecasting all kinds of macroeconomic trends and even AI, and issuing reports on these issues.”
Na Shin-pyeong Takes First Place in Best Report; Han Ki-pyeong Not Among the Top Three
At the 37th SRE Best Report Awards, a report by Na Credit Rating—which addressed the macroeconomic market and sector-specific impacts resulting from soaring interest rates—received the highest score. The Best Report is selected based on the report that received the most votes out of a total of 15 reports submitted by the three credit rating agencies. In this year’s SRE Best Report, Nara Credit Rating took first place, Han Shin Credit Rating secured second and third, and Han Ki Credit Rating ranked fourth and fifth. At the 36th SRE, all three agencies—Han Ki-pyeong in 1st place, Na Shin-pyeong in 2nd, and Han Shin-pyeong in 3rd—were included in the top three, but this year, only Na Shin-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong made the top three.
It is noteworthy that the topics of the reports ranked at the top of the Best Reports list were largely similar. Na Shin-pyeong’s series titled “Entry into a Period of Rising Interest Rates: Outlook on Impacts by Financial Sector and In-Depth Analysis of Vulnerable Sectors,” which took first place, received 46 votes (12.6%) out of a total of 366 votes (with respondents allowed to select up to two reports from among 15 nominees). Han Shin Rating’s “Rising Interest Rates” series, which took second place in the Best Reports, received 42 votes (11.7%). While both the first- and second-place reports covered market conditions during a period of rising interest rates—and thus shared a similar theme—it is interpreted that the reports containing more in-depth analysis—a total of five reports from Na Shin Rating and three from Han Shin Rating—received more votes.
Han Shin Rating’s “U.S.-Iran War” series, which took third place in the Best Reports, received 42 votes (11.5%). Comprising a total of eight reports, this series boasted the most extensive volume among this year’s Best Report nominees. The reports provided a multifaceted analysis of the geopolitical risks arising from the U.S.-Iran conflict—which has persisted since the beginning of the year—and their resulting impacts on the credit market and various industries. Ranked fourth was Han Ki-pyeong’s “Risks of the U.S.-Iran War and Sector-by-Sector Impacts” (30 votes, 8.2%), which was classified as a report with similar content. In fifth place was Han Ki-pyeong’s “The Pillars of AI Growth: Memory Semiconductors and Data Centers,” which received 29 votes (7.9%); this result appears to reflect the market’s intense interest in AI amid the semiconductor boom.
By sector, the series “Entry into a Period of Rising Interest Rates: Outlook on Impacts by Financial Sector and In-Depth Analysis of Vulnerable Sectors” by Na Credit Rating—which ranked first among both CA and non-CA respondents—received the most votes. It received 13 votes (11.5%) from CA respondents and 33 votes (13.0%) from non-CA respondents. In terms of total votes by credit rating agency, Han Shin Rating took first place with 132 votes, followed by Han Ki Rating with 121 votes and Na Shin Rating with 113 votes.
One SRE advisory committee member explained, “The top four rankings all revolve around macro issues such as rising interest rates and a potential U.S.-Iran war,” adding, “In the past, credit rating agencies were often evaluated as being strong in analyzing individual companies but weak in macro analysis; it seems they are continuing to produce macro reports to overcome this weakness.”
Na Shin-pyeong “Consolidates” Seminar Satisfaction for Third Consecutive Year
In the seminar satisfaction evaluation, Na Credit Rating maintained its first-place ranking for the third consecutive year. After ranking first in the 31st and 32nd seminars, Na Credit Rating lost the top spot to Han Credit Rating from the 33rd to the 34th seminars, but has successfully solidified its lead this year, following its first-place finishes in the 35th and 36th seminars. When asked which organization had the highest seminar satisfaction, Na Shinpyeong received 27 votes (33.8%). Han Shinpyeong ranked second with 21 votes (26.3%). Han Ki-pyeong received only 14 votes (17.5%), fewer than the “no difference” response (18 votes, 22.5%). To ensure the accuracy of the survey, respondents with a seminar attendance rate of 20% or less were excluded.
An SRE advisory committee member stated, “The corporate bond market sentiment wasn’t good this year, and the macro topics were all quite similar, so it seems that respondents who attended many seminars were more likely to answer ‘no difference.’” Another SRE advisory committee member expressed disappointment, saying, “Korea Ratings conducted this seminar in a panel discussion format, but since participants merely stated their own opinions without offering any new information, the discussion devolved into predictable, diplomatic rhetoric.”
At the 37th SRE, the business contribution of research reports and seminars scored 4.09 out of 5. Although this represents a slight decline from last year’s 4.14, it marks the fifth consecutive year the score has exceeded 4 points since it rose to the 4-point range at the 33rd SRE (4.02). In particular, the fact that the CA Group awarded a high score of 4.40 indicates that the credit rating agencies’ research reports and seminars are proving helpful in actual business operations. One SRE advisory committee member stated, “It’s difficult to score above 4 out of 5 even in a company’s 360-degree evaluation, so a satisfaction rating in the 4-point range for research reports and seminars suggests a level of satisfaction that is not sustainable,” adding, “Ultimately, it seems that the number of exposures and the volume of reports are driving the survey results.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
The following is a summary of the report series titled “Assessing the Impact of a U.S.-Iran War by Industry,” which took third place in the Best Report category at the 37th SRE Awards. On February 28,…
Daesang ( Daesang(001680)) is donating Cheongjeonwon food sets worth 100 million won to help vulnerable residents in Jongno-gu, Seoul, get through the winter.
Daesang’s Head of ESG Management, Kim …
Graphy has unveiled integrated digital dentistry solutions in collaboration with dental equipment manufacturer Ray, covering everything from diagnosis to the production of orthodontic appliances. The …