Debate Over 'Compromise Proposal' for Mandatory Tender Offers… PEF Burden vs. Shareholder Rights [Market In]
EQT, Bain, and TPG to Purchase Remaining Shares at the Same Price Following Commercial Code Amendment
Private Equity Fund Association: "Funding Burden Is Heavy"... On Pro-rata Allocation: "Incentives for Major Shareholders to Sell Are Reduced"
If the Financial Services Committee’s proposal is adopted, Aekyung Industries and Lotte Rental would have a mandatory buyout obligation of “0 shares” for general shareholders
[Edaily Marketin Song Seung-Hyeon Reporter] Opinions are evenly divided regarding the impact the mandatory tender offer system will have on the mergers and acquisitions (M&A) market, with the debate even spilling over into a roundtable discussion chaired by the President.
Following the introduction of directors’ fiduciary duty to shareholders through amendments to the Commercial Act, a series of mandatory tender offers for all remaining shares has led to criticism that the National Assembly’s amendment lags behind market practices. On the other hand, the private equity fund (PEF) industry opposes the measure, citing financial burdens, and counters that since a significant number of these full-scale buyouts were intended for delisting, it is difficult to use them as a basis for management control transactions in general. (Photo: Image generated by AI Gemini.) According to the investment banking (IB) industry on the 17th, President Lee Jae-myung demanded evidence at the “Capital Market Policy Roundtable” held at the Korea Exchange on the 13th regarding whether mandatory tender offers actually stifle M&A activity. President Lee asked, “If the financial burden on those conducting mergers and acquisitions becomes so great that the deals themselves fall through, won’t minority shareholders lose the opportunity altogether?” Park Byeong-geon, chairman of the Private Equity Fund Management Association, stated that an increased financial burden could lead to a decline in domestic acquisitions and argued that the Financial Services Commission’s proposal—centered on the “50% + 1 share” threshold—is realistic. In contrast, Kim Woo-chan, a professor in the Department of Business Administration at Korea University, countered that he had found no evidence of a decline in corporate acquisitions in countries that have adopted the system.
According to a study (co-authored by Professor Kim and others) cited in a report released the same day by the Yeouido Investor Rights Research Institute, affiliated with Hanuri Law Firm, the average control premium for block trades in the 37 countries that have adopted mandatory tender offers fell from 60.2% to 23.0%, but the number of transactions did not decrease significantly. This year, EQT Partners acquired Duzon Bizon, and Bain Capital acquired Eco Marketing, purchasing all remaining shares through a tender offer at the same price paid to the major shareholders. TPG also acquired a 61.17% stake in Lotte Rental and is currently conducting a tender offer for the remaining 38.83% at the same price.
However, a significant number of these transactions were aimed at delisting, which requires securing a stake of around 95%. If a mandatory full buyout were required for management-control transactions intended to maintain a listing, the burden on acquirers would increase. While domestic private equity funds (PEFs) have 43.2 trillion won in dry powder (according to the Financial Supervisory Service), critics point out that the number of asset managers capable of handling transactions in the trillions of won is limited because blind funds typically have a single-investment limit of 20–25% of their committed capital. They argue that the domestic PEF environment, which relies on institutional funds such as the National Pension Service, must also be taken into account.
Chairman Park also expressed concerns about the pro-rata allocation method. Under this method, when the number of shares tendered exceeds the purchase volume, both major shareholders and general shareholders are allowed to sell only the same proportion of their holdings. In such cases, a major shareholder who intended to divest all their shares ends up selling only a portion and retaining the rest. Chairman Park noted that this reduces the incentive for major shareholders to sell, and acquirers may also find it burdensome to have the former major shareholder remain as the second-largest shareholder. Duzon Bizon and Eco Marketing conducted two to three tender offers, and Macquarie raised its price by 10.4% after its first tender offer for Gabia fell through. This illustrates that even a full tender offer entails significant costs. The Financial Services Commission also noted that some studies have reached conclusions opposing this approach.
The alternative proposal from the National Assembly’s Political Affairs Committee—which the private equity fund (PEF) industry viewed as realistic—stipulated that an acquirer must first purchase the major shareholder’s stake and then conduct a tender offer only for the portion of “50% of the total issued shares plus one share” minus the stake already acquired. If the major shareholder holds a majority stake, the mandatory tender offer volume becomes zero shares. Opponents argue that the Political Affairs Committee’s proposal could infringe on the rights of minority shareholders.
Last October, the Taekwang Group consortium agreed to purchase a 63% stake in Aekyung Industries at approximately 1.9 times the closing price on the day before the announcement. Minority shareholders were left to bear the burden of a falling stock price without any opportunity to sell. Aekyung Industries’ stock price is currently about 30% lower than it was on the day before the announcement. Under the bill, this transaction would result in a mandatory purchase of 0 shares. Lotte Rental, where TPG voluntarily offered to purchase all shares, also qualifies as “0 shares” under the bill’s criteria. Hannuri analyzed that 15 out of 35 major controlling-interest transactions worth over 300 billion won since 2015 fall into this category. Critics point out that if statutory requirements are merely met, the board of directors would have grounds to cooperate with such transactions, which could actually weaken the protection of minority shareholders.
The amendment passed the Political Affairs Committee and the Legislation and Judiciary Committee last September, but its consideration by the plenary session has been postponed. President Lee stated, “In any case, we must reach a conclusion.” The Democratic Party of Korea plans to discuss adjustments to the purchase ratio again at its policy meeting of lawmakers today, and some within the party are even suggesting raising the ratio to 75 percent.
It has been revealed that the share of SamsungElectronics and its subsidiaries in SamsungElectroMechanics’ total revenue has decreased. As business with global big tech companies expands, particularly…
#SANIGEN Co., Ltd., a molecular diagnostics company specializing in microorganisms, has filed a patent for proprietary technology capable of detecting the dengue virus in just one hour, marking the of…
With the U.S. government introducing export control regulations that block Chinese companies from accessing overseas data centers via workarounds, changes are expected in the global competition to att…