[Edaily Reporter Kim Kyung-eun ] Although the KOSPI rebounded just one day after falling below the 5,000 mark, analysts in the securities industry say it is still too early to conclude that the market has bottomed out. This is because, despite the index plummeting more than 45% from its peak, the extreme panic selling typically seen in past market crashes has not been prominent. While foreign selling is driving the index lower, retail investors’ capacity for further investment is also dwindling. Consequently, analysts predict that the KOSPI could fall further to the 4,600 level, and it remains unclear whether the short-term rebound will lead to a sustained upward trend.
According to MP Doctor on the 18th, the KOSPI closed at 5,067.44, up 1.99% from the previous trading day. On the previous day (the 17th), the KOSPI fell 2.6%, dropping below the 5,000 mark for the first time in about nine months, but it successfully reclaimed that level today. This rebound is attributed to bargain-hunting following the recent sharp decline, with stocks that had suffered the largest losses leading the recovery.
However, analysts note that it remains unclear whether the rebound will continue, as uncertainties surrounding NVIDIA’s management and concerns about a slowdown in artificial intelligence (AI) capital expenditures have not been resolved. There are also concerns that market volatility could increase again ahead of major events such as Anthropic’s initial public offering (IPO).
Even during past market crashes, short-term rebounds did not necessarily lead to a trend reversal. According to an analysis by Daishin Securities of KOSPI crashes since 1980, the probability that stock prices would rise one month after buying at the first closing price following a 40% decline from the peak was only 40%. In contrast, the probability of an increase 12 months later rose to 80%. This suggests that while the likelihood of a medium- to long-term rebound following a sharp decline is high, further corrections may occur in the short term.
In particular, this downturn differs from past sharp declines in that investor panic selling has not been particularly pronounced relative to the magnitude of the drop. Since hitting a high of 9,114.55 on June 22, the KOSPI has fallen 45.5% over 100 trading days, closing at 4,968.48 yesterday. Compared to the 56% decline over about a year and a half during the 2000 information technology (IT) bubble and the 54% decline over about a year during the 2008 global financial crisis, the current decline has been concentrated in a shorter period.
The KOSPI 200 Volatility Index (VKOSPI), which measures market fear, has actually been declining. According to Eugene Investment & Securities, while the VKOSPI soared to between 83 and 88 last July when the KOSPI hit a new low, it has remained between 49 and 65 on days when the index hit new lows since October. Even on the previous day, when the KOSPI fell below the 5,000 mark, the VKOSPI stood at just 53.6.
Fund flows in the stock market are also cited as a factor making it difficult to be optimistic about a short-term rebound. According to the Korea Financial Investment Association, investor deposits stood at 86.6228 trillion won as of the previous day, a 38% decrease from the all-time high of 139.6947 trillion won recorded on June 4. Compared to the end of September and October, the figures have fallen by 17.2% and 4.0%, respectively, suggesting that retail investors’ capacity to invest is gradually shrinking.
Foreign capital flows and a recovery in AI-related investor sentiment are cited as key factors that will determine whether the rebound will continue. In particular, the key question is whether investor sentiment toward global tech stocks—which has improved since Anthropic’s IPO—will return, shifting the focus away from IPOs.
Lee Jun-young, an analyst at Eugene Investment & Securities, stated, “There are no signs of a market bottom accompanied by a sell-off yet,” adding, “Since the index continues to decline even after margin liquidations have ended, it is spot selling (by foreign investors) that is driving the current downturn.” He added, “A slowdown in foreign selling will also be a leading indicator of a market bottom,” noting, “With customer deposits having fallen below their levels at the start of the year, there is no reason to rush into bargain hunting; maintaining a higher cash position is more advantageous than chasing a rebound.”
Daishin Securities projected the lower bound of the KOSPI’s trading range for the fourth quarter of this year at 5,200, while leaving open the possibility of further corrections following the recent sharp decline. Lee Kyung-min, an analyst at Daishin Securities, noted, “Technically, the 4,911 level—the intraday low on the 6th—is a critical juncture,” and analyzed, “If the market falls below this level, the final wave of the downtrend will prolong, and the bottom will likely be confirmed around the 4,580–4,670 range around December 1, when November’s export figures are released.”