With the 2027 College Scholastic Ability Test just one day away, the government announced it would pay up to 100 million won to those who report cheating, prompting a flood of criticism on online communities where parents gather. One poster said, “I can’t understand why the government is shifting its responsibilities onto the children.”
A reward system offering tens of millions of won was hastily cobbled together based on a single remark by the president. As the government seeks to drastically expand its whistleblower reward system under the pretext of promoting public interest reporting, criticism is mounting that it is shifting the government’s responsibilities onto the public and fostering a “surveillance society.”
According to relevant government agencies on the 19th, this CSAT reward program is being introduced abruptly in accordance with President Lee Jae-myung’s wishes. After President Lee directed on the 17th that rewards for reporting cheating using advanced electronic devices should be “at least 100 million won per incident, with additional amounts based on the number of cheaters,” the government formalized the policy of “up to 100 million won per incident” within a single day. However, no specific details were disclosed regarding eligibility, criteria, budget line items, or funding sources. In effect, the government promised the maximum reward amount without first completing the necessary procedures, such as establishing a legal basis for payment or developing a detailed implementation plan.
This measure aligns with the government’s ongoing push to expand the whistleblower reward system. According to the Ministry of Strategy and Budget and other sources, the government plans to eliminate reward caps for reports of tax evasion, collusion, and stock price manipulation starting next year, and to establish new reward programs for violations of the Price Stability Act (such as hoarding) and breaches of trade secrets. To this end, the government has established a Public Interest Whistleblower Incentive Fund and allocated a reward budget of 254.6 billion won—eight times the amount of the previous year—signaling the dawn of an unprecedented “era of whistleblower rewards.”
However, concerns have been raised that the new introduction and expansion of reward programs could lead to an increase in reports motivated by personal vendettas or “paparazzi-style” tips aimed solely at collecting rewards. In fact, officials from agencies that have operated reward systems for decades agree that such cases are not uncommon. A former National Tax Service official stated, “There was a case where someone who had embezzled hundreds of millions of won in investment funds from an acquaintance—after being sued for fraud—submitted records of money transfers made under the guise of interest payments as evidence, reported the acquaintance for ‘evading interest income tax,’ and even demanded a reward.”
It is also difficult to guarantee that abolishing the reward cap will lead to an increase in high-quality reports. In the case of rewards for reporting tax evasion, the payment limit was raised from 1 billion won in 2013 to 4 billion won in 2018, but it has been confirmed that the largest payout on record was less than 2 billion won.
Critics also argue that policies actively encouraging citizens to act as “watchdogs” and “whistleblowers” could undermine trust in the community and foster distrust. Kang Seong-jin, a professor of economics at Korea University, said, “If the reward system for reporting tax evasion is expanded too broadly, it could result in institutionally encouraging mutual surveillance among citizens, similar to North Korea’s ‘Five-Person Responsibility System,’ which is undesirable.”