Legal Affairs

'SM Stock Price Manipulation': Kakao's Kim Beom-soo Acquitted on Appeal… "Insufficient Evidence of Artificial Manipulation" (Comprehensive)

Co-defendants Bae Jae-hyun and Hong Eun-taek Also Acquitted Court: "Intent to Manipulate Market Prices and Conspiracy Not Proven" Ji Chang-bae Found Guilty of Embezzlement and Breach of Trust in Separate Case… Appeals by Both Parties Dismissed Kim Beom-soo: "I Will Contribute to Kakao’s New Challenges and Innovation"

Lee So-Hyun
2026-11-20 11:12:53
[Edaily Reporter Lee So-Hyun ] Kim Beom-soo Kakao(035720), the founder of SM Entertainment who was indicted on allegations of stock price manipulation, was acquitted in the appellate court, following his acquittal in the first trial. The court ruled that it was difficult to conclude that Kakao’s purchase of SM Entertainment shares was intended to artificially manipulate the stock price, and that there was insufficient evidence to support the allegations of price manipulation or conspiracy.

Consequently, the founder’s legal risks—which have persisted for over three years—have been significantly alleviated. It is expected that Kakao will also be able to reduce management uncertainty and accelerate its revitalization through a shift toward artificial intelligence (AI) and a corporate spin-off.

Kakao founder Kim Beom-soo, head of the Future Initiative Center, shares his thoughts outside the courthouse immediately after being acquitted in the appellate trial on the 20th. (Photo: ReporterLee So-Hyun )


The Seoul High Court’s Criminal Division 4-1 (Presiding Judges Kim In-gyeom, Seong Ji-yong, and Jeon Ji-won) upheld the lower court’s acquittal on the 20th of Kim Beom-soo, head of Kakao’s Future Initiatives Center, and others indicted on charges of violating the Capital Markets Act, and dismissed the prosecution’s appeal.

The court also upheld the acquittals on market manipulation charges for Bae Jae-hyun, former Chief Investment Officer of Kakao; Hong Eun-taek, former CEO of Kakao; Kim Seong-su, former CEO of Kakao Entertainment; Kang Ho-jung, former Head of Investment Strategy at Kakao; Kim Tae-young, former Deputy CEO of One Asia Partners; and Ji Chang-bae, CEO of One Asia Partners, who were all tried alongside Kim Beom-soo. The acquittals for the corporations—Kakao, Kakao Entertainment, and One Asia Partners—were also upheld.

However, CEO Ji was found guilty of separate charges of embezzlement and breach of trust under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes, and the sentence handed down in the first trial—three years in prison, suspended for four years—was upheld. The court dismissed both the prosecution’s and CEO Ji’s appeals.

(Graphic by Reporter Lee Mi-na)


“Insufficient Evidence of Artificial Market Manipulation”… Acquittal Upheld on Appeal Following First-Instance R
uling
Founder Kim and others were indicted on charges of artificially inflating the stock price to obstruct HYBE’s tender offer in February 2023, while Kakao was competing with HYBE for control of SM Entertainment.

At the time, HYBE was conducting a tender offer for SM Entertainment shares at 120,000 won per share. The prosecution determined that Kakao, along with the private equity firm One Asia Partners and others, submitted a total of 553 orders intended to manipulate the market—including 350 high-price buy orders, 196 limit-out orders, and 7 closing-price intervention orders—to keep the stock price above the tender offer price.

In response, the first-instance court acquitted the defendants last October, ruling that it was difficult to conclusively determine that Kakao’s large-scale stock purchases constituted market manipulation and that there was insufficient evidence to establish that Founder Kim and others had conspired to manipulate the market.

In particular, the trial court found that the testimony of Lee Mo, the former head of the Investment Strategy Division at Kakao Entertainment—which the prosecution presented as key evidence—lacked credibility, and that the objective nature of the orders made it difficult to view them as market manipulation.

The prosecution appealed, arguing that the first-instance ruling contained errors of fact and misinterpretations of the law. At the final hearing of the appellate trial last September, the prosecution sought a 15-year prison sentence and a fine of 500 million won for Founder Kim.

However, the appellate court reached the same conclusion as the trial court.

The court explained, “To punish trading for the purpose of fixing or stabilizing prices—as prohibited by Article 176, Paragraph 3 of the Capital Markets Act—it must be established that the trading activity involved artificial manipulation of prices naturally formed in the market.”

In particular, the court pointed out, “While all trades in the securities market can influence market prices, punishing even purchases that do not involve artificial manipulation on this basis could lead to an unlimited expansion of the scope of punishment.”

The court also emphasized that routine on-exchange purchases made to secure friendly stakes during tender offers or hostile mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are permissible transactions.

The court ruled, “It is difficult to view Kakao’s actual orders as exhibiting the characteristics of high-price purchases, volume depletion, or closing-price manipulation intended to artificially raise or prop up the stock price.” It further determined that the evidence submitted by the prosecution alone was insufficient to prove that the defendants had the intent to fix or stabilize market prices through artificial manipulation or that they had conspired to do so.

Furthermore, the court ruled that the charge of violating the obligation to report large shareholdings—which was based on the premise of a conspiracy between former CEO Bae, CEO Ji, and founder Kim—could not be upheld.

The court also upheld the lower court’s ruling regarding separate charges of embezzlement and breach of trust against CEO Ji. The court found that the first-instance court’s determination—that transferring funds from the victimized fund to accounts in his own and his mother’s names constituted embezzlement in the course of business—was justified, and that the sentence was appropriate.

For these reasons, the court dismissed both the prosecution’s and CEO Ji’s appeals.

Kim Beom-soo, head of Kakao’s Future Initiatives Center, who was acquitted in the first trial on charges of conspiring to manipulate SM Entertainment’s stock price, attends the appellate sentencing hearing held at the Seoul High Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 20th. (Photo = Yonhap)


“I Will Contribute to Kakao’s New Challenges and Innovation”… Expectations for a Fresh Start

Immediately after the acquittal, Founder Kim was seen smiling brightly as he shook hands with his co-defendants, who had stood alongside him in court, and told them, “You’ve been through a lot.”

Speaking to reporters outside the courthouse, he said, “Now that my acquittal has been confirmed in the appellate court, following the first trial, I hope this marks the end of the uncertainty that has hung over Kakao for the past four years.”

He continued, “I would like to thank all executives and employees who worked hard in their respective roles during this difficult time, and I am grateful to everyone who has consistently offered their warm support.”

He emphasized, “Now, as the AI era reshapes every industry, I will do everything in my power as Kakao’s founder to support the company’s new challenges and innovations.”

Center Director Kim has been responding to investigations and trials for over three years, beginning with a summons for questioning by the Financial Supervisory Service’s Special Judicial Police in October 2023. He was detained in July 2024 but released on bail after approximately 100 days.

With this acquittal significantly alleviating the founder’s legal risks, attention is now focused on Kakao’s future direction as the company pushes forward with its transition to AI-centric operations and the development of new businesses.

Kakao plans to restructure through a spin-off next February, creating “Kakao AI,” which will focus on KakaoTalk-based advertising, commerce, and AI businesses, and “Kakao X,” which will be responsible for investing in and fostering affiliates in areas such as tech-fin, content, and mobility.

Kim Beom-soo, Head of Kakao’s Future Initiatives Center, visited the training site for the 2026 new graduate recruitment program underway at the Kakao AI Campus in Yongin, Gyeonggi Province, on January 15. (Photo: Kakao)

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

Sell-off After Sell-off… All Eyes on Inflation Indicators [Lee Jeong Hun’s Coin Weekly Review]

The price of Bitcoin plummeted to around $55,000 at one point during the week. This marked its lowest level in over two years. Having previously recorded six consecutive weeks of decline—a feat that h…
2026-11-22 10:28:20

Corporation

"Beyond the Domestic Home Shopping Market to Vietnam": GS Retail Sees Success in Export Consultations with Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises

GS Retail(007070)has supported domestic small and medium-sized partner companies in Vietnam in expanding their overseas sales channels, resulting in export consultation deals totaling approximately $1…
2026-11-22 18:23:06

IT·Science

“One Game Rakes in 5 Trillion Won in a Single Day”… UK Networks Set New Records Amid GTA 6 Craze

A single video game generated $3.79 billion (approximately 5 trillion won) in sales worldwide on its first day of release. Pre-orders alone totaled 32.5 million copies before the official launch. As u…
2026-11-22 16:57:26