Taxes

55 million won in just 3 minutes?…The Downfall of an Uncle and Nephew’s ‘Single-Home Tax Exemption’ Loophole [Tax GO]

Kim Mi-Young
2026-11-15 07:40:03
[Sejong = E-Daily Reporter Kim Mi-Young ] An uncle who faked the sale of his home to his nephew in order to claim the “one household, one home” tax exemption was caught out by his financial transaction records. Just before the purported sale, the uncle withdrew tens of millions of won, and the exact same amount was deposited into his nephew’s account at the same bank branch in just three minutes—leaving a “suspicious flow of funds” that served as evidence of the sham transaction. After transferring the home to his nephew, the uncle regained ownership two years later but was ultimately required to pay capital gains tax, plus a surcharge for fraudulent underreporting.

According to the tax industry on the 15th, the Tax Tribunal recently dismissed an appeal filed by Uncle A, who had transferred a house to his nephew but regained ownership after the agreement was rescinded, challenging the National Tax Service’s assessment of capital gains tax.

The case dates back to 2021. Uncle A transferred a home in Gyeonggi Province, which he co-owned with his spouse, to his nephew, Mr. B. This was done to qualify for the “one household, one home” tax exemption when selling another residence. At the time, Mr. A also owned another home; approximately four months after transferring the home to his nephew—in June 2021—he sold that home and filed a tax return claiming a capital gains tax exemption.

However, the home transferred to his nephew reverted to Mr. A’s ownership in January 2023 through a mutual agreement to rescind the transfer. Tax authorities suspected that the transaction was not a legitimate sale from the outset but rather a sham transaction designed to meet the requirements for tax exemption.

The decisive evidence came from financial transaction records. On February 9, 2021, Mr. A withdrew 55 million won. Then, three minutes later, 55 million won was deposited into Mr. B’s account at the same bank branch. The tax authorities focused on this transaction, which took place 12 days before the payment for the house was exchanged. They interpreted this as evidence that the nephew, Mr. B, had not purchased the home with his own money but had paid the purchase price using funds Mr. A had sent him in advance. They concluded that this was a sham sale—where the title was merely transferred to make it appear as if the home had been sold to the nephew, but no actual sale had taken place. Consequently, they revoked the “single-home tax exemption,” reassessed the capital gains tax, and imposed a surcharge for fraudulent underreporting.

The surcharge for fraudulent underreporting applies not merely to cases of underreporting taxes, but only when there is active fraudulent conduct that renders the assessment and collection of taxes impossible or significantly difficult. While the standard surcharge rate for underreporting is 10%, a rate of 40% is applied if the conduct is deemed fraudulent.

Mr. A objected, arguing that he had not engaged in active fraudulent conduct for the purpose of tax evasion, but the Tax Tribunal rejected this claim. The Tribunal cited several grounds, including the fact that the petitioner transferred the home to his nephew immediately before selling another home to receive the tax exemption benefit and then regained ownership; the fact that the amounts of money withdrawn by the petitioner and deposited into the nephew’s account matched; and the fact that the timing of the transactions was closely aligned.

The Tax Tribunal concluded that Mr. A had engaged in active conduct—specifically, a sham sale with his nephew—that significantly obstructed the assessment and collection of capital gains tax, and therefore ruled that the application of a 40% surcharge for fraudulent underreporting was justified.

AI-generated image

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Issue] BBB-Rated Market Stifled by the JR and JoongAng Crisis

“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
2026-11-18 10:30:05

Corporation

'Gyochon Makgeolli' Served at APEC Banquet… Available at the Grand Hyatt Hotel

KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
2026-11-18 09:50:52

IT·Science

SillaJen, Inc.’s Anticancer Virus ‘SJ-650’ Selected for National New Drug Development Project… Moving Forward with Preclinical Trials

SillaJen, Inc.(215600)The company is receiving government support for the development of “SJ-650,” a next-generation anticancer viral therapy administered via intravenous injection. It plans to accele…
2026-11-18 10:02:02