[37th SRE][Worst] CJ CGV Drops in Rankings, but… “Downward Pressure Persists”
[37th SRE]
From 2nd Place Last Year to a Tie for 18th… 12 Out of 13 Votes Were “Downward”
Three Credit Rating Agencies Simultaneously Remove 'Positive' Outlooks at End of June
Debt Ratio Reduced to 600 Billion Won Through Hybrid Capital Securities
[Edaily Marketin Song Seung-Hyeon Reporter] CJ CGV ranked tied for 18th in the 37th SRE Worst Rating. This marks a drop of 16 spots from its second-place ranking last year. Although the company posted a net profit in the second quarter thanks to its overseas operations and the consolidation of CJ Olive Networks, the prevailing view was one of downgrade due to losses at its domestic theaters and a financial structure reliant on hybrid capital securities.
◇Ranking Fell, but 92% Favor a Downgrade
Of 197 bond market experts, 13 (6.6%) responded that CJ CGV’s current credit rating is inappropriate. Of these, 12 (92.3%) favored a downgrade, while only one favored an upgrade. There was virtually no difference in the vote share between Credit Analysts (CA; 6.5%) and non-CA respondents (6.7%).
The three major domestic credit rating agencies have assigned CJ CGV an “A- (Positive)” rating since June 2024. In this year’s periodic reviews, Korea Ratings maintained the rating on June 29, while Korea Hana Rating and NICE Rating maintained the rating on June 30 and changed the outlook to “Stable.” One SRE advisory committee member said, “CJ CGV has always been near the bottom of the ratings, but this time it dropped significantly,” adding, “Since they’ve dropped the ‘positive’ outlook and are now rated only ‘A-,’ doesn’t that mean the market may not view it as positive, but at least considers it ‘stable’?” Another advisory committee member pointed out, “Still, there are many who voted to downgrade it.”
Theaters Are in the Red, Subsidiaries Are Profitable… Debt-to-Equity Ratio Lowered Through Hybrid Capital Securities
CJ CGV’s consolidated operating revenue last year rose 16.2% to 2.2754 trillion won, while operating profit increased 26.7% to 96.2 billion won. However, the company posted a net loss of 143.4 billion won after accounting for financial expenses of 197.8 billion won, an impairment loss on right-of-use assets of 53.9 billion won, and an impairment loss on intangible assets of 50.8 billion won. In the second quarter of this year, operating revenue rose 20.8% to 594 billion won. Operating profit increased to 11.5 billion won compared to the same period last year (1.7 billion won), and the company returned to profitability with a net income of 22.6 billion won.
However, domestic theaters remain in the red. On a standalone basis, the operating loss was 49.5 billion won last year and 12.8 billion won in the first half of this year (compared to 48.3 billion won in the same period last year). By segment for the first half of the year, multiplex operations posted an operating loss of 4.6 billion won. In contrast, IT services (CJ Olive Networks) recorded an operating profit of 31.3 billion won, and the specialized technology theater division (4DPLEX) posted an operating profit of 7.5 billion won.
After redeeming existing hybrid capital securities in the first quarter, CJ CGV issued new hybrid capital securities with an interest rate of 6.10% in both April and May, totaling 300 billion won each. As capital decreased due to the redemption, the debt-to-equity ratio soared from 534% at the end of last year to 835% at the end of March. By the end of June, following the completion of the new issuances, the ratio had fallen to 412%. Net debt, excluding lease liabilities, also increased from 625.6 billion won to 883.9 billion won during the same period before declining to 583.8 billion won. The debt-to-equity ratio fluctuates significantly depending on the timing of the redemption and issuance of hybrid capital securities, which are classified as equity. Its subsidiary, 4DPLEX, also secured 220 billion won in investment in redeemable convertible preferred shares (RCPS), including 50 billion won from the National Growth Fund’s High-Tech Strategic Industry Fund. Investors can request that CJ CGV repurchase their shares starting five years from now. One advisory committee member noted, “I understand that CJ Group affiliates are also struggling because of CJ CGV.” It remains to be seen whether the recovery of the domestic theater market will lead to the rating stabilizing rather than declining further.
[This article was published in the 37th edition of the SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
SillaJen, Inc.(215600)The company is receiving government support for the development of “SJ-650,” a next-generation anticancer viral therapy administered via intravenous injection. It plans to accele…