[37th SRE][Survey] “Lego Land Nightmare Repeats”: Han Shin Rating Plummets to Last Place… Han Ki Rating Achieves First Place for Fifth Consecutive Year
[37th SRE]
Korea Ratings Maintains Top Spot for Fifth Consecutive Year with a Score of 3.78
NICE Ratings Maintains Rating Despite Proactive Adjustment, Ranks Second
Han Shin Rating Posts Largest Drop Among the Three Agencies… Ranks Last After Falling 0.09 Points
JR and JoongAng Group’s Successive Bankruptcies Call into Question Their “Pro-Business” Image
[Edaily Marketin Reporter LEE GEON-EOM ] Korea Ratings (KRI) took the top spot in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category of the 37th Edaily Survey of Credit Rating Experts (SRE), maintaining its number one position for the fifth consecutive year since the 33rd survey. Korea Credit Rating Agency (KCR), which tied with HanKiPyeong for first place last year, saw the sharpest drop in scores among the three agencies and slipped to third place. NICE Credit Rating (NICE) was the only one of the three credit rating agencies to maintain its score, rising to second place. Analysts suggest that this year’s string of defaults by investment-grade companies weighed on the credibility of credit rating agencies.
Last year, KCR outperformed KRA in areas such as quality improvement efforts, the appropriateness of proactive recommendations, and satisfaction with rating reports. This year, however, KRA surpassed KCR in all four categories, including the reliability of credit ratings. NICE Credit Rating maintained its first-place position in the categories of quality improvement efforts and the appropriateness of proactive recommendations, continuing to demonstrate its strengths.
Korea Ratings Takes
First Place for the Fifth Consecutive Year… Han Shin Rating Slips to Third
In the 37th SRE survey on credit rating reliability by agency, Han Ki-pyeong scored 3.78 points, surpassing Na Shin-pyeong (3.75 points) and Han Shin-pyeong (3.74 points). It extended its streak of first-place finishes—which had spanned from the 33rd to the 36th surveys (where it tied for first)—to five consecutive times. The point difference between first and third place was 0.04 points, the smallest since the 30th survey.
However, the scores of all three agencies fell short of the overall reliability score (4.00 points). An SRE advisory committee member commented, “While the overall assessment is positive, the memory of poor individual agency performances led evaluators to be particularly strict and deduct points, resulting in lower scores.”
In terms of scores alone, Han Ki-pyeong also took a step backward. Peaking at 3.95 in the 33rd round, its score dropped to 3.86 in the 34th and 35th rounds, then to 3.83 in the 36th round, and finally fell to 3.78 this year—the lowest score since the 30th round. It managed to retain the top spot as its competitors’ scores either stagnated or declined.
A series of defaults by investment-grade companies has weighed on the credibility of credit rating agencies, including Han Shin Rating, this year. On April 27, JR Global REITs filed for rehabilitation proceedings with the Seoul Rehabilitation Court after failing to repay the principal and interest on 40 billion won in corporate bonds. This was due to a sharp decline in the asset value of its core asset, the Finance Tower in Belgium, which caused a breach of the loan-to-value (LTV) covenants, as well as a “cash trap” situation where rental income was prioritized for debt repayment.
Subsequently, on June 12, JTBC defaulted on its securitized loan repayment; on the 14th, major shareholders including Joongang Holdings, Contentree Joongang, Megabox Joongang, and Joongang P&I filed for rehabilitation proceedings; and on the 15th, JTBC itself filed for rehabilitation. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “The most regrettable aspect for Korea Ratings this year is JR Global REIT.” However, some analysts suggest that since institutional exposure to JR Global REIT was not significant, the decline in Korea Ratings’ credibility was limited.
In particular, Han Shin Rating saw its score drop to 3.74 points—a decrease of 0.09 points from the previous survey (3.83 points)—marking the largest decline among the three agencies. Following a drop to 3.67 points in the 33rd survey in the wake of the Legoland incident, its upward trend—which had continued with scores of 3.68 in the 34th, 3.79 in the 35th, and 3.83 in the 36th—came to an end, and it slipped to third place for the first time in three years since the 34th survey. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “There were issues with Han Shin Rating’s response to the Lego Land incident, and with the JR and Joongang Group cases piling on top of that, hasn’t its credibility suffered?”
It has also been pointed out that Han Shin Rating’s image as being “corporate-friendly” has become a burden. One respondent, who gave Han Shin Rating the lowest score among the three agencies, commented, “There are signs of credit rating adjustments that are somewhat corporate-friendly,” adding, “We’ve also observed instances where ratings (and outlooks) are adjusted quickly when upgraded but slowly when downgraded.”
In the survey’s open-ended questions, there were also negative opinions regarding Han Shin Rating’s aggressive sales tactics. One respondent stated, “I understand that Han Shin Rating has recently been engaging in aggressive sales activities, such as offering customized seminar services,” adding, “While proactive communication is positive, excessive sales efforts can be a burden for both parties, so it would be better to exercise restraint.”
Na Credit Rating received a score of 3.75, the same as in the previous survey, and rose to second place for the first time in three years since the 34th survey. The gap with first-place Han Credit Rating is 0.03 points. Analysts suggest that Na Credit Rating benefited from the fact that it does not hold a valid rating for JR Global REIT.
An SRE advisory committee member said, “When Nara Credit Rating first downgraded Lotte’s credit rating, it faced a lot of criticism and received poor evaluations,” adding, “In hindsight, however, it has begun to receive recognition for making the right call.” However, some survey participants also expressed the opinion that “while Nara Credit Rating has the edge in terms of the degree of improvement, Han Ki Credit Rating and Han Shin Credit Rating still lead in absolute terms.”
Managers Leave Han Shin-pyeong… Juniors Head to Na Shin-pyeong
When broken down by job function, Han Shin Rating’s decline was particularly pronounced among non-credit analysts (non-CA), including bond managers. Non-CA respondents gave Han Shin Rating a score of 3.61, which was lower than the scores for Han Ki Rating (3.69) and Na Shin Rating (3.63). Hanshin Rating’s non-CA score—which had been rising from 3.65 in the 34th survey to 3.69 in the 35th and 3.79 in the 36th—fell below the level of the 34th survey. Managers, who had driven Hanshin Rating to first place last year, awarded the agency a score of 3.65 this year, a 0.16-point drop from the previous survey (3.81). Manager ratings were as follows: Korea Ratings (3.68 points), Han Shin Rating, and Na Shin Rating (3.64 points).
Non-CA professionals, including portfolio managers, directly use credit ratings to select securities and set investment limits; therefore, they are inevitably sensitive to the speed and direction of rating adjustments. If a downgrade is delayed, they only belatedly recognize risks that have already been reflected in market interest rates, and that burden directly impacts investment performance. It is interpreted that the perception of being reluctant to make downgrades has eroded Hanshin Rating’s credibility among practitioners who use ratings in their actual investment decisions.
Credit analysts (CAs) awarded Han Shin Rating and Na Shin Rating 4.00 points each. Han Ki Rating received 3.98 points, marking a decline for the second consecutive year—following 4.01 points in the 35th survey and 3.99 points in the 36th—and slipping to third place among the CA group. Na Shin Rating’s CA score rose by 0.24 points from last year’s 3.76. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “The CA survey results showed that Han Shin Rating’s credibility was surprisingly high.”
By years of experience, preferences diverged between senior and junior staff. In the group with 7 or more years of experience (133 respondents), Han Ki-pyeong led with a score of 3.76, ahead of Han Shin-pyeong (3.69) and Na Shin-pyeong (3.68). Conversely, in the 1–6 years group (64 respondents), Na Shin-pyeong scored 3.89 points, higher than Han Ki-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong (both 3.83 points).
In the 1–3-year group (41 respondents), Na Credit Rating also outperformed Han Ki Rating (3.90 points) and Han Shin Rating (3.83 points) with a score of 3.93 points. Na Credit Rating, which received the lowest scores across all tenure groups last year, rose to first place in the junior group this year. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “Senior employees rated Han Ki-pyeong more highly, while the lower the seniority, the higher the rating for Na Shin-pyeong, making Na Shin-pyeong popular among younger employees.”
By institution, securities firm CAs (20 respondents) awarded Han Ki-pyeong a score of 4.15, giving it a higher rating than Han Shin-pyeong (3.95) and Na Shin-pyeong (3.90). Among asset management firm CAs (32 respondents), Na Shin-pyeong scored 4.09, ahead of Han Shin-pyeong (3.97) and Han Ki-pyeong (3.94). Han Ki-pyeong, which received a score of 4.16 from asset management firm CA last year, dropped 0.22 points and fell to third place.
In terms of satisfaction with rating reports, Han Ki Rating reclaimed first place with a score of 3.85. Na Shin Rating maintained second place with 3.81, while Han Shin Rating—last year’s leader—fell 0.15 points to 3.79, slipping to third place. An SRE advisory committee member explained, “In terms of individual corporate rating assessments, Han Ki-pyeong consistently receives high marks,” adding, “Since they do a good job of standardizing and disclosing financial statements, many junior analysts are drawn to the firm as they begin their careers.”
By job category, in the CA group, the rankings were Han Ki-pyeong (4.02 points), Na Shin-pyeong (3.97 points), and Han Shin-pyeong (3.95 points); in the manager group, Na Shin-pyeong led with 3.81 points, ahead of Han Ki-pyeong (3.77 points) and Han Shin-pyeong (3.73 points). The number of respondents who use reports more than 20 times a month was 49, down from 65 last year. In this group, Han Ki-pyeong (4.18 points) and Na Shin-pyeong (4.16 points) took first and second place by a narrow margin, while Han Shin-pyeong scored only 3.98 points. Na Shin-pyeong’s score rose from 4.09 points last year.
Na Shin-pyeong
Leads in
Proactive Opinion Provision for 4 Consecutive Years
In the category of appropriateness of proactive opinion provision, Na Shin-pyeong ranked first for the fourth
consecutive year
since the 34th survey, with a score of 3.67. Han Ki-pyeong scored 3.59, and Han Shin-pyeong scored 3.55. In the “Quality Improvement Efforts” category, Na Credit Rating also led with a score of 3.76, ahead of Han Ki Rating (3.68) and Han Shin Rating (3.66). The scores for quality improvement efforts were lower than last year for all three firms. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “There is a general consensus that quality improvement efforts are a recognized strength of Na Credit Rating,” adding, “However, the absolute score has dropped slightly compared to last year.”
The trend of each rating agency’s strengths becoming more firmly established also continued. An SRE advisory committee member remarked, “The pattern of awarding the ‘Reports’ category to Han Ki-pyeong and the ‘Seminars and Initiatives’ category to Na Shin-pyeong has persisted for several years.” In terms of seminar satisfaction, Na Shin-pyeong maintained its top position, receiving 27 votes (33.8%) out of 80 respondents (excluding those with an attendance rate of less than 20%). Han Shin-pyeong rose from third place last year to second, with 21 votes (26.3%), while Han Ki-pyeong fell from second to third, with 14 votes (17.5%).
One SRE advisory committee member commented, “Han Ki-pyeong conducted this year’s seminar in a panel discussion format, but it amounted to nothing more than participants stating their own opinions without providing any new information,” adding, “While new attempts are welcome, I’m not sure how effective they were.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
Korea Ratings (KRI) took the top spot in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category of the 37th Edaily Survey of Credit Rating Experts (SRE), maintaining its number one position for the fifth consecutiv…
CJ CheilJedang Corp. is taking steps to create a sustainable and safe sports environment by utilizing the biodegradable biomaterial “PHA” (polyhydroxyalkanoates). The company plans to introduce PHA-ba…
Korean pharmaceutical and biotech stocks saw sharply divergent performance on November 16 as investors reacted to clinical news. Corestem ChemOn hit the daily upper limit after clarifying its U.S. app…