Selling More Yields Less Profit, Selling Less Yields More Profit… The Food Industry’s Growth Formula Is Shaken
Mixed Results for 11 Food Companies as Third-Quarter Sales and Profits Improve
Daesang, Nongshim, OTOKI, and Dongwon F&F: Sales Rise, Profits Fall
Binggrae and HITEJINRO Defend Profitability by Cutting Advertising and Logistics Costs
SamyangFoods and LOTTE WELLFOOD See Profit Margins Rise Amid Strong Overseas Growth
[Edaily Reporter Kim Ji-woo ] The food industry’s third-quarter earnings this year revealed a business environment in which it has become difficult to secure profitability through sales growth alone. While some companies saw their profits decline despite increased sales due to rising cost pressures, others managed to boost profits through cost-cutting measures or by expanding overseas sales. Analysts note that the industry’s key challenge is now to move beyond short-term cost reductions and establish a business structure where sales growth translates into profit growth.
According to the food industry on the 17th, Daesang(001680),Nongshim(004370),Ottogi(007310), and Dongwon F&F all saw their third-quarter revenue increase year-over-year, but their operating profits all declined. While these companies’ revenue growth rates were 3.0%, 6.7%, 2.3%, and 4.0%, respectively, operating profit fell by 12.9%, 8.6%, 34.5%, and 55.4%. This reflects the fact that even though they expanded their scale, they were unable to fully offset the increased costs incurred during production and sales.
Year-over-year changes in third-quarter earnings for major food companies. (Graphic: Image generated by ChatGPT) Consequently, operating profit margins also declined. OTOKI’s operating profit margin, which was approximately 5.8% in the third quarter of last year, fell to 3.7% this year. Nongshim’s margin dropped from 6.2% to 5.3%, and Daesang’s fell from approximately 4.1% to 3.5%. Dongwon F&F’s margin also fell from approximately 5.4% to 2.3%.
The reasons behind the cost increases vary by company. For Nongshim, in addition to domestic cost pressures, advertising and promotional expenses rose from 20.4 billion won to 29.3 billion won, and transportation and storage costs increased from 36.5 billion won to 39.9 billion won. Daesang also saw its profits squeezed by rising costs in its materials business and increased export expenses. Dongwon F&F faced cost pressures stemming from rising tuna prices and a strong exchange rate, compounded by promotional competition among distribution channels. As costs rose across various stages—from production to transportation and sales—the benefits of sales growth were diminished.
Even among companies that saw increases in both sales and operating profit, the situation varied by business segment. CJ CheilJedang Corp(097950)reported third-quarter sales of 4.23 trillion won and operating profit of 203 billion won—up 5.7% and 6.9%, respectively—excluding CJ LOGISTICS(000120). Within this, sales in the lifestyle food business rose 3.8% to 2.5744 trillion won, but operating profit remained flat at 118.7 billion won compared to last year. Despite growth in global strategic products such as dumplings and Haetban, as well as new domestic categories, the food business was unable to increase its profits amid rising costs for raw materials and logistics.
Tightening the Belt on Advertising and SG&A Expenses
Some companies have absorbed the impact of declining sales by cutting costs. Binggrae and HITEJINRO saw their third-quarter sales decline by 4.8% and 5.5%, respectively, but their operating profits rose by 10.7% and 6.2%. These are examples of companies defending their profits by adjusting expenditures—such as advertising and logistics—amid shrinking sales volumes.
At Binggrae, advertising and promotional expenses fell from 10.7 billion won in the third quarter of last year to 7.6 billion won this year, while transportation and warehousing costs dropped from 13.1 billion won to 9.9 billion won. Although gross profit decreased by approximately 5 billion won, this was offset by a reduction of more than 11 billion won in total selling, general, and administrative expenses.
HITEJINRO also cut its advertising and promotional expenses by approximately 18.8 billion won. Although profits from product sales fell by about 13.2 billion won due to declining revenue, the company reduced selling, general, and administrative expenses—including advertising costs—by approximately 16.5 billion won.
Cost Management Is Essential Even With Rising Overseas Sales
Some companies are smiling thanks to the rapid growth of their overseas businesses. SamyangFoods(003230)reported third-quarter revenue of 791.8 billion won and operating profit of 196.2 billion won, up 25.3% and 49.9%, respectively. The operating profit margin rose from approximately 20.7% to 24.8%. Overseas sales rose 29.4% to 660.8 billion won, supporting the overall profit growth.
LOTTE WELLFOOD also saw a higher contribution to profits from its overseas operations. While total revenue rose only 1.5% to 1.1739 trillion won, operating profit increased by 29.7% to 89.9 billion won. This was largely driven by a 137.8% increase in operating profit from overseas subsidiaries to 23.1 billion won. The stabilization of the Choco Pie production line in India, the expansion of sales regions, and growth in both domestic and export markets in Kazakhstan all contributed to an improvement in the overall operating profit margin from approximately 6.0% to 7.7%.
Of course, even as overseas operations grow, they are not free from cost pressures. ORION saw revenue rise 11.3% to 922.7 billion won and operating profit increase 9.4% to 150.9 billion won, driven by growth at its Chinese and Russian subsidiaries; however, the overall operating profit margin fell slightly from approximately 16.6% to 16.4%. Although the Vietnamese subsidiary saw an 8.4% increase in revenue, operating profit fell by 0.8% due to factors such as rising raw material prices.
In some cases, one-time costs associated with business restructuring led to a deterioration in profitability. Pulmuone Corporate saw revenue rise 3.0%, but operating profit fell 89.6% to 4 billion won. The company explained that this reflected both the burden of raw material costs and one-time expenses incurred to streamline its workforce structure.
An industry official stated, “Amid continued sluggish domestic demand, performance varied depending on the burden of raw material and logistics costs, as well as the level of advertising and promotional spending.” The official added, “Even if overseas sales increase, the net profit varies depending on local production and distribution costs; therefore, the ability to manage profitability by product and channel, in addition to sales volume, has become even more important.”
It has been revealed that the share of SamsungElectronics and its subsidiaries in SamsungElectroMechanics’ total revenue has decreased. As business with global big tech companies expands, particularly…
The food industry’s third-quarter earnings this year revealed a business environment in which it has become difficult to secure profitability through sales growth alone. While some companies saw their…
Members of the SAMSUNG BIOLOGICS Win-Win Labor Union hold a lunchtime rally at the company’s BioPark last month. (Photo courtesy of the SAMSUNG BIOLOGICS Win-Win Labor Union)
SAMSUNG BIOLOGICS(207…