Issues & Trends

[37th SRE][Worst] Meritz Financial Leads in ‘Upgrade’ Prospects… Aims for Bank-Level Rating Beyond ‘AA’

[37th SRE] Ranked 4th in Worst Ratings… Opinions Favoring a Credit Rating Upgrade Prevail Assessment of Capital Strength Among Leading Securities Firms… “Challenge to Bank-Level Ratings” Homeplus and Real Estate Exposure: Variables Amid “Manageable” Conditions

Hur Jieun
2026-11-18 08:00:05
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] Meritz Financial Holdings ranked fourth in the 37th SRE Worst Rating survey. Included in the survey for the first time this year, 41 out of 197 bond market experts (20.8%) responded that Meritz Financial Holdings’ current credit rating is inappropriate. However, unlike other companies in the top ranks of the “Worst” list, the reason cited was not that the rating was “too high,” but rather that it was “too low.” Of the 41 respondents, 28 (68.3%) said the rating should be upgraded, more than double the number who recommended a downgrade (13, or 31.7%).


Meritz Financial Group’s current credit rating for unsecured bonds is “AA (Stable)” according to Han Shin Rating. Its core subsidiaries—Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance—hold an Insurance Financial Strength Rating (IFSR) of “AA+,” while Meritz Securities holds an “AA” rating. In March of this year, both Korea Ratings and NICE Ratings upgraded Meritz Securities from “AA-” to “AA,” and in September, the company also received authorization to issue commercial paper (short-term finance business). An SRE advisory committee member interpreted this, saying, “Aren’t securities firms’ assets growing larger than those of banks these days?” and added, “This reflects both government policies aimed at fostering securities firms and market sentiment that Meritz, as a leading player in the securities industry, should aim for a bank-level rating (AA+).”

Profits and Capital Provide Backing… Homeplus Remains a Variable

The numbers lend weight to the case for an upgrade. According to Han Shin Rating, Meritz Financial Group’s consolidated assets swelled to 148.5 trillion won as of the end of June, and net income rose from 2.1254 trillion won in 2023 to 2.3501 trillion won last year. Net income for the first half of this year stood at 1.4716 trillion won. The average return on assets (ROA) over the past three years (2023–2025) is 2.0%.

Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance’s solvency ratio stands at 230.5%, the highest in the industry, while Meritz Securities’ net capital ratio reaches 1,885.9%. NICE Ratings assessed that Meritz Securities’ equity capital last year (7.5 trillion won) was more than double the “AA-” securities firm average (3.2 trillion won). On a standalone basis for the holding company, dividend income from subsidiaries is expected to rise to 1.3 trillion won in 2024 and was around 1.33 trillion won last year, which is sufficient to cover interest expenses and selling, general, and administrative expenses. The company is also actively engaged in shareholder returns, having net purchased 846.5 billion won worth of treasury stock in the first half of this year alone.

However, the rationale behind the downgrade recommendations (13 analysts) is also clear. Han Shin Rating pointed out that the consolidated non-performing loan ratio rose to 7.2% after approximately 1.2 trillion won in Homeplus-secured loans were classified as non-performing last year, and that total real estate exposure amounts to 32.7 trillion won, equivalent to 255% of consolidated capital. The holding company’s standalone double leverage ratio stands at 127.8%, approaching the threshold for a downgrade set by Han Shin Rating (consistently exceeding 130%).

Although the company holds the first-priority beneficial interest in the Homeplus store collateral trust and executed an additional 200 billion won in DIP financing in August based on joint guarantees from MBK Partners and others, analysts assess that there is uncertainty regarding the timing of recovery through the disposition of collateral. On September 11, Han Shin Rating maintained the rating of “A+, Stable” for Meritz Financial Group’s 11th series of hybrid capital securities. The key factors for a potential upgrade are expected to be the recovery of the Homeplus exposure and the management of the holding company’s leverage.

An SRE advisory committee member pointed out, “Meritz Securities and Meritz Capital have also suffered damage in terms of their metrics,” adding, “The Homeplus issue remains unresolved, and it is difficult to say there are no potential risks.”

[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Issue] BBB-Rated Market Stifled by the JR and JoongAng Crisis

“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
2026-11-18 10:30:05

Corporation

'Gyochon Makgeolli' Served at APEC Banquet… Available at the Grand Hyatt Hotel

KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
2026-11-18 09:50:52

IT·Science

SillaJen, Inc.’s Anticancer Virus ‘SJ-650’ Selected for National New Drug Development Project… Moving Forward with Preclinical Trials

SillaJen, Inc.(215600)The company is receiving government support for the development of “SJ-650,” a next-generation anticancer viral therapy administered via intravenous injection. It plans to accele…
2026-11-18 10:02:02