Even after earnings took a hit due to the electric vehicle “chasm” (a temporary lull in demand), EcoPro’s debt ballooned by more than 900 billion won in just six months as the company continued to invest in raw materials, such as nickel smelters. EcoPro BM’s planned 1.2 trillion won rights offering also shrank to 886.1 billion won due to a decline in its stock price. The market’s view is sobering. Of the 25 experts who identified the two companies as “worst-rated,” 23 believed the low ratings were appropriate.
12th → 9th… All 12 CA Analysts ‘Downgrade’In the 37th Edaily Credit Rating Expert Survey (SRE: Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily), EcoPro BM and EcoPro ranked 9th on the “worst-rated” list, as 25 out of 197 bond market experts (12.7%) responded that their current credit ratings were inappropriate. This marks a three-rank rise from 12th place in the 36th survey last year (22 respondents, 9.9%), when they first appeared on the list.
The sentiment regarding the rating outlook leaned heavily toward a downgrade. Of the 25 respondents, 23 recommended a downgrade, while only 2 recommended an upgrade. The number of downgrade recommendations was 11.5 times that of upgrade recommendations, widening the gap significantly compared to last year (16 versus 6). For companies with split ratings—where opinions differed—respondents indicated an upgrade if the higher rating was deemed appropriate, and a downgrade if the lower rating was deemed appropriate.
By job category, 12 out of 62 credit analysts (CA) (19.4%) cited these two companies, representing the highest proportion of respondents. All 12 responded that a downgrade was necessary. Credit analysts (CAs) did not cast a single vote in favor of an upgrade for the second consecutive year. Among non-credit analysts (non-CAs), whose opinions were split last year—with 6 favoring an upgrade and 5 favoring a downgrade—11 out of 13 this year sided with the downgrade.
“Neg
ative”
Outlook for High Ratings… Capital Increases Decline While Debt Rises
Both companies are in a “split” situation, with differing ratings from credit rating agencies. EcoPro has been assigned a “BBB+ (Stable)” rating by Korea Ratings (KR) and an “A- (Negative)” rating by NICE Credit Rating (NICE). EcoPro BM has been rated ‘A- (Stable)’ by KRA and ‘A (Negative)’ by Korea Credit Rating Agency (KCRA). All rating agencies that assigned the higher ratings have attached a ‘Negative’ outlook, leaving the door open for a downgrade.
According to the Financial Supervisory Service’s electronic disclosure system, EcoPro’s total consolidated debt rose by 931.1 billion won over the past six months, from 3.7707 trillion won at the end of last year to 4.7018 trillion won at the end of June. This increase was partly due to the addition of 402.5 billion won in debt following the consolidation of Green Eco Nickel (GEN), a nickel smelter in Indonesia, as a subsidiary. During the same period, net debt rose from 2.5839 trillion won to 3.3654 trillion won, and the debt-to-equity ratio increased from 117.9% to 124.5%. Of EcoPro BM’s total debt of 2.8960 trillion won, more than 1.7000 trillion won is due within one year.
The rights offering also fell short of expectations. Due to a decline in the stock price, which lowered the issue price, EcoPro BM raised only 886.1 billion won. Of the funds raised, 765 billion won will be used to invest in a stake in the BNSI nickel smelter in Indonesia, and 121.1 billion won will be allocated to the plant in Hungary. NICE Ratings predicted that, since most of the capital raised through the stock offering will be used for investments, the financial burden across the entire group will remain high.
EcoPro maintains that since it is executing investments with the highest priority on maintaining financial soundness, the risks that could affect its credit rating are limited. An EcoPro official stated, “The loans paid on behalf of EcoPro BM during the BNSI investment process are scheduled to be recovered sequentially,” adding, “Since the investment special purpose vehicle (SPV) is proceeding smoothly with attracting external investors and securing its own financing, the additional financial burden on the holding company will not be significant.”
[This article was published in the 37th edition of the SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]