[37th SRE][Worst] Hotel Shilla: Impact of Withdrawal from Airport Duty-Free… “Rating Should Be Raised”
Although tied for 14th place, 13 out of 16 votes were for an “upgrade”
Duty-Free Operating Profit Reaches 46 Billion Won in First Half Following DF1 Withdrawal
NICE Ratings Outlook Returns to 'Stable'… Recovery of Duty-Free Sales Remains a Challenge
[Edaily Marketin, Reporter Song Seung-Hyeon ] Hotel Shilla tied for 14th place in the 37th SRE Worst Rating. This marks a six-rank rise from last year’s 20th place. However, the underlying sentiment is quite the opposite. Most experts who selected Hotel Shilla believed its rating should be raised.
81% of Respondents Called for an “Upgrade”
Out of 197 bond market experts, 16 (8.1%) responded that Hotel Shilla’s current credit rating is inappropriate. Of these, 13 (81.3%) said the rating should be raised, while only 3 recommended a downgrade. Among respondents, 9.7% (6) of those identified as credit analysts (CA) and 7.4% (10) of those not identified as CA cited Hotel Shilla.
All three domestic credit rating agencies have assigned Hotel Shilla an “AA-” rating. NICE Rating lowered the rating outlook to “Negative” in April of last year, citing declining performance in the duty-free sector and increased debt burden. In its regular review this past June, NICE Ratings revised the outlook back to “Stable,” noting that the fixed rent burden had been significantly reduced following the closure of the DF1 business. Hanwha Credit Rating and Korea Ratings maintained their “AA-” ratings in their regular reviews this past April.
Cutting Off the Bad Apple Leads to Profit Rebound… But Duty-Free Sales Have Yet to Recover
Hotel Shilla secured the DF1 operating rights in the 2023 bidding process by offering a rent of 8,987 won per passenger. As losses mounted, the company applied to the court for a rent adjustment, but Incheon International Airport Corporation objected to the compulsory adjustment proposal. At a board meeting on September 18 of last year, Hotel Shilla resolved to suspend operations in the DF1 zone (cosmetics, perfumes, alcohol, and tobacco), and ceased operations on April 16 of this year. Although DF1 generated 429.3 billion won in revenue in 2024—accounting for 10.9% of consolidated revenue—it posted an operating loss of around 20 billion won every quarter.
A loss of 230.2 billion won from the termination of the concession rights, primarily due to penalty payments, was recorded as a non-operating expense last year. Although operating profit turned positive at 13.5 billion won last year, the net loss ballooned to 172.8 billion won due to this loss. Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization (EBITDA) increased from 127.1 billion won in 2024 to 154.3 billion won last year.
The TR (duty-free) division posted an operating loss of 53.1 billion won last year but generated an operating profit of 46.0 billion won in the first half of this year alone—11.0 billion won in the first quarter and 35.0 billion won in the second quarter. Consolidated operating profit for the second quarter was 61.1 billion won, seven times that of the same period last year (8.7 billion won), and the company recorded 55.2 billion won in the third quarter as well. Net income for the third quarter turned positive at 38.4 billion won. Cumulative operating profit for the first through third quarters totaled 136.7 billion won, 7.8 times the figure for the same period last year (17.6 billion won). This reflects the immediate impact on earnings of the company’s restructuring of its duty-free business, including the closure of its Macau Airport store last November.
Consolidated revenue for the third quarter was 959 billion won, down 6.5% from the same period last year. The duty-free operating profit margin also declined from 4.7% in the second quarter to 3.6% in the third quarter. Mirae Asset Securities cited the cost burden of inventory purchased during a period of high exchange rates, the off-season for “daigou” (personal shoppers), and increased rental costs at overseas airports as the causes. The brokerage firm projected that duty-free sales this year would decline by 7.0% to 3.1 trillion won, analyzing that most of the profit growth would stem not from increased demand but from cost normalization resulting from the withdrawal from unprofitable operations.
Korea Investment & Securities lowered its target price by 23% in just one month, from 73,000 won to 56,000 won. This reflects the assessment that foreign tourists are diversifying their spending to destinations such as department stores, and that the recovery in the duty-free industry in the second half of the year will fall short of the first half’s performance. Analysts suggest that a rating upgrade will require confirmation of a recovery in duty-free sales volume.
Hotel Shilla stated, “As our earnings remain stable, we will focus even more on sound management,” adding, “The TR division will strive to improve profitability in line with the recovery in inbound demand driven by the Chinese National Day holiday and the expansion of China-Korea air routes, while the Hotel & Leisure division will focus on foreign customers and year-end demand.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th edition of the SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
SillaJen, Inc.(215600)The company is receiving government support for the development of “SJ-650,” a next-generation anticancer viral therapy administered via intravenous injection. It plans to accele…