[37th SRE][Issue] Revised Commercial Code Strengthens Shareholder Rights… But What Happens to “Creditors’ Rights”?
[37th SRE]
Shareholder Rights Strengthened Through Three Amendments
Creditor Protection Measures Remain Unchanged Since Their 1962 Design
Expert: “Mandatory Corporate Bond Management Firms and Rally Requirements Need to Be Revised”
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] While shareholder rights have been strengthened through three rounds of amendments, creditors remain bound by a framework designed over 60 years ago. Three amendments to the Commercial Act have been enacted: the expansion of directors’ fiduciary duties in July 2025; the mandatory adoption of the cumulative voting system and the expansion of separate elections for audit committee members in September of the same year; and the mandatory cancellation of treasury stock in March of this year. There is significant concern that as companies prioritize shareholder interests, the position of creditors may weaken, yet the system designed to protect creditors has remained stagnant for decades. Experts have emphasized the need to address the “gap in creditor protection” following the implementation of the amended Commercial Act.
[Photo = Yonhap News]
“The bond market has grown, but protection mechanisms remain unchanged”
At a seminar last April, Han Shin Rating pointed out that if shareholder-friendly decision-making intensifies following the implementation of the amended Commercial Act, the stability of creditors’ recovery could be undermined, creating the potential for a “transfer of wealth” between shareholders and creditors. This is because excessive dividends reduce a company’s ability to absorb losses in times of crisis through retained earnings. As a countermeasure, the agency viewed it as crucial to implement structural measures, such as setting more conservative financial covenants than before when issuing corporate bonds and restricting the scope of dividend and capital policies.
The problem lies in workarounds. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “Everyone is thinking of other ways—ways to circumvent the amended Commercial Act,” citing as an example the trend of re-merging companies that had previously been split off as a result of difficulties in providing support to affiliates. The member added, “Since the amendment to the Commercial Act itself strengthens shareholder interests, there is a contradictory aspect to it (from the creditors’ perspective).”
During mergers and spin-offs, the issuing company must publicly announce matters subject to creditor objections, and bondholders must obtain approval through a bondholders’ meeting. However, industry observers assess that these measures lack practical effectiveness. An SRE advisory committee member lamented, “For creditors to be protected, they must gather one-third of the creditors, but there’s no way to know who the other creditors are.” While shareholders have a shareholder registry, creditors have no way of knowing who holds their bonds.
In fact, a resolution at a bondholders’ meeting requires at least two-thirds of the voting rights present and at least one-third of the total bond amount, and holders of bearer bonds must deposit their bonds one week prior to the meeting. The Capital Markets Research Institute pointed out that the provisions of the Commercial Act establishing these procedures have remained unchanged since their enactment in 1962. This advisory committee member reported that, even during the merger of Korean Air and Asiana Airlines, they considered allowing creditors to file objections but ultimately determined that it would be impossible to gather enough creditors.
Even if a merger or similar transaction is approved, the structure does not require the issuer to repurchase the bonds. While bonds are redeemed at face value in the event of a loss of the benefit of the term (EOD), this is not the case here. Shareholders have a right of squeeze-out if they oppose the deal, but bondholders do not. It is explained that the recent SK Innovation buyback was also not mandatory. There was also a prevailing view that creditors are not being adequately protected, citing the fact that even Meritz, a secured creditor, is being asked to make sacrifices during the Homeplus rehabilitation process.
Proposals for improvement have already been put forward. Prompted by the JTBC incident, the Korea Financial Research Institute proposed mandating the establishment of corporate bond management companies, improving the requirements for participation in bondholder meetings, and introducing a meeting system for short-term bonds. Currently, the law does not mandate the establishment of corporate bond management companies, and even when their designation is required, the issuing company retains the right to choose the entity. The Korea Capital Market Institute analyzed that the Commercial Act should be amended to allow bondholders to attend meetings simply by proving their status as bondholders, and suggested considering electronic meetings in the long term.
An SRE advisory committee member stated, “While the bond market has grown tremendously and become highly active, the system for protecting bondholders does not seem to have developed accordingly,” adding, “Bondholders’ interests may be infringed upon, yet they are not being adequately protected.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
SillaJen, Inc.(215600)The company is receiving government support for the development of “SJ-650,” a next-generation anticancer viral therapy administered via intravenous injection. It plans to accele…