Issues & Trends

[37th SRE][Issue] The True Nature of Equity Securities: Using Debt to Cover Debt

[37th SRE] Debt 46%, Hybrids 39%… “Equity” at 14% Concerns Over Inadequate Incorporation of PRS in Credit Ratings and Potential Widespread Market Impact LG Chem Adds 2.5 Trillion Won to PRS… Domestic Balance Exceeds 20 Trillion Won

Hur Jieun
2026-11-18 11:30:06
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] Domestic companies are flocking to “equity securities.” This year, eight securities firms have issued won-denominated hybrid capital securities totaling 2.755 trillion won. The value of domestic equity price swaps (PRS) contracts, which stood at just 403.8 billion won in 2023, rose to 5.3946 trillion won in 2024 and 9.6709 trillion won last year; this year, with major conglomerates such as POSCO and LG signing new contracts, the figure is on the verge of reaching a record high.

How do bond market experts view these financing instruments, which are treated as equity transactions or recognized as capital for accounting purposes? While capital securities are regarded as a new source of funding that lays the groundwork for companies to pursue new business ventures, concerns are also growing that the increasing volume of off-balance-sheet financing could lead to potential credit risks in the future.

Only 14% View Them as “Equity”… 46% as Debt, 39% as Hybrid

In the 37th SRE survey, 91 out of 197 valid respondents (46.2%) answered that capital securities—such as new capital securities and PRS—are “closer in nature to debt.” This was followed by 76 respondents (38.6%) who said they “should be viewed as hybrid (equity + debt),” while only 27 (13.7%) said they “are closer to equity.” Combined, responses classifying them as debt or hybrid accounted for 84.8%.

By job category, 38 out of 62 credit analysts (CAs) (61.3%) viewed them as closer to debt, whereas among the 135 non-CAs, the “hybrid” response (56 respondents, 41.5%) outnumbered the “debt” response (53 respondents, 39.3%). Only one CA (1.6%) responded that they viewed it as closer to equity, while 26 non-CAs (19.3%) did so. Some respondents expressed opinions such as, “While the nature is hybrid, the issuance conditions of domestic companies (short maturities, step-up clauses, etc.) give it a strong debt character,” and “New capital securities are equity, while PRS is debt.”

Hybrid capital securities have long maturities of 30 years or more, and since issuers can extend the maturity, they are recognized as equity for accounting purposes if certain requirements are met. However, issuers often consider early redemption when the first call option becomes exercisable. They also possess bond-like characteristics, such as the accrual of additional interest on unpaid interest.

Han Shin Rating assigns a rating to Meritz Financial Group’s hybrid capital securities that is two notches lower than that of senior unsecured bonds. It also calculated a separate adjusted double leverage ratio for the holding company by subtracting the outstanding balance of hybrid capital securities (approximately 1.2 trillion won) from equity and adding non-equity liabilities such as payment guarantees, resulting in a figure of 277.8%. This is more than double the ratio disclosed in public filings (127.8%). Daishin Securities issued 140 billion won in hybrid capital securities this year and used all of the proceeds to repay commercial paper (CP). In effect, the company swapped short-term debt for long-term securities that are recognized as capital.

PRS Hits 20 Trillion Won… “Off-Balance-Sheet Financing” on the Rise

A PRS is a derivative-linked transaction in which a company sells its shares to a securities firm but settles the difference in stock price at maturity. It is typically structured using a parent company’s stake in a subsidiary as the underlying asset. While legal rights are transferred to the investor, the risk of a falling stock price remains with the company. Han Shin Rating views PRS as off-balance-sheet financing that, while formally a share transaction, also possesses the characteristics of a borrowing transaction from an economic perspective.

The PRS market has grown rapidly. According to Han Shin Rating, the outstanding balance of PRS contracts—which had remained below 1 trillion won through 2023—surpassed 20 trillion won as of September of this year. By industry, the cumulative issuance amount is highest for holding companies (25.1%), followed by secondary batteries (20.0%) and petrochemicals (19.4%). By corporate group, SK (7.3 trillion won), Hanwha (3.6 trillion won), POSCO (2.5 trillion won), LG (2 trillion won), and Lotte (1.8 trillion won) stand out. By type, “sales of listed shares”—in which held listed shares are sold—accounts for 46.1%, while “subsidiary capital increases”—linked to paid-in capital increases by subsidiaries—account for 32.8%.

Han Shin Rating analyzes “subsidiary capital increase-type” PRS as a structure in which the parent company effectively provides credit enhancement for the subsidiary’s fundraising. SK Innovation is a prime example. The outstanding PRS balance related to new shares issued by SK On and SKIET totals 3.8 trillion won, accounting for approximately 54% of the SK Group’s total (7.1 trillion won), and the group recognized 1.2169 trillion won in derivative valuation losses in the first half of this year alone. The total financial exposure—calculated by simply adding corporate bonds, commercial paper, securitized securities (808.7 billion won), and PRS—amounts to 9.8 trillion won, meaning that 4.6 trillion won, equivalent to 88% of marketable debt, is effectively off-balance-sheet.

LG Chem also announced last October that it would raise 2.5 trillion won through a PRS utilizing its stake in LG Energy Solution. The plan essentially involves disposing of a 2.79% stake (approximately 6.53 million shares) in LG Energy Solution via a two-year PRS. This is the second such transaction following the PRS issued last November (5.75 million shares, 2 trillion won) and is part of a plan to reduce its ownership stake to around 70% by 2030. Korea Ratings Agency noted that while the impact on LG Chem’s (AA) credit rating would be limited, the improvement in financial metrics would be modest—with net debt decreasing from 27.5932 trillion won to 25.9932 trillion won and the debt-to-equity ratio falling from 129.6% to 125.5%. The settlement base amount, combined with the existing PRS, is approximately 4.5 trillion won; if LG Energy Solution’s stock price falls below the reference price (347,500 won per share for contracts signed last year) at the time of disposal, a cash settlement may occur.

“Could Spread Across the Market” 3.72 points

Responses regarding the extent to which the actual credit risks associated with the expansion of equity securities such as PRS (including settlement burdens in the event of a stock price decline and concerns about overhang) are reflected in credit ratings or market prices averaged 2.52 out of 5 points (with lower scores indicating less reflection). Scores of 1–2 were given by 113 respondents (57.4%), accounting for more than half, while 28 respondents (14.2%) gave scores of 4–5. Regarding the potential for this financing method to spread beyond being an exceptional measure for companies facing business downturns to become a common practice among high-quality large corporations—thereby posing a potential risk to the credit market as a whole—the average score was 3.72 (higher scores indicate greater concern). A total of 133 respondents (67.5%) rated it 4–5 points, while 17 (8.6%) rated it 1–2 points; those with CA (4.03 points) viewed the situation more negatively than those without CA (3.58 points).

The structure of equity securities was cited as a reason why this risk is difficult to reflect. Han Shin Rating pointed out that PRS agreements sometimes include triggers—such as margin calls (requests for additional collateral) or early settlement upon a credit rating downgrade—which could lead to a sudden surge in cash outflows during periods of deteriorating creditworthiness. SK Innovation and Lotte Chemical are cited as examples of companies with credit rating trigger clauses. Four risk pathways were identified: debt volatility, liquidity strain, real interest rate burden, and the spillover of risk across affiliates. Even if these are not classified as interest expenses for accounting purposes, they are equivalent to high-interest borrowing on a cash basis; furthermore, if multiple affiliates accumulate similar financing, the group’s overall capacity to provide support and its ability to refinance could both decline. Jeong Ik-su, a senior analyst at Han Shin Rating, pointed out, “When a group’s PRS balance is large, it is difficult to assess the actual credit risk by looking at individual contracts alone.”

Credit rating agencies are also in the process of developing analytical frameworks. Han Shin Rating views the marketability of the underlying assets and the presence of early settlement triggers as key factors. While the agency has proposed a method of treating unlisted or overseas underlying assets—either in part or in full—as de facto debt, it maintains that credit rating criteria must be established cautiously due to non-public information and conditions that vary by case. However, this survey clearly reveals the disconnect: while the accounting treatment classifies these as equity and equity transactions, the market perceives them as effectively debt.

One SRE advisory committee member explained, “The market views PRS almost entirely as debt because the structure involves settling only the difference in stock prices,” adding, “At best, it can be considered a hybrid.” Another SRE advisory committee member noted that “credit rating agencies have recently been issuing many reports related to PRS,” indicating that the market is watching the situation closely.

[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Issue] BBB-Rated Market Stifled by the JR and JoongAng Crisis

“The bond market should be a universal channel for corporate financing, but right now it’s like an exclusive social club.”This was the point raised by an advisory committee member during a meeting hel…
2026-11-18 10:30:05

Corporation

'Gyochon Makgeolli' Served at APEC Banquet… Available at the Grand Hyatt Hotel

KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
2026-11-18 09:50:52

IT·Science

K-Games Dominate Google Play's 'Game of the Year' List

Google Play announced the “2026 Best of the Year” on the 18th, highlighting the apps and games that were most popular among users over the past year. In South Korea, Nexon’s “Maple Grow” was…
2026-11-18 11:22:31