[37th SRE][Issue] Only Lotte, the “Regular,” Remains… SK Makes a Comeback to Rank First as the “Most Rational Group”
[37th SRE]
Lotte Ranks First for Two Consecutive Years in "Need for Restructuring" and "Inappropriateness"
Shinsegae Ranks Second in Both Categories… Burden of Acquiring SSG.com Stake
SK Ranks First in Rational Management Strategy; Samsung Second, Hyundai Motor Third
[Edaily Marketin LEE GEON-EOM Reporter] Lotte Group has ranked first for the second consecutive year on a list of “groups in need of restructuring” compiled by bond market experts. It also ranked first in a survey asking which groups have inappropriate restructuring trends and management strategies, receiving negative evaluations regarding both the necessity and direction of restructuring. Shinsegae rose to second place in both categories, partly due to the burden of acquiring a stake in SSG.com. In contrast, SK—which, along with Lotte, was frequently cited as a group in need of restructuring last year—was recognized for its rebalancing achievements and ranked first among groups with sound management strategies. In the 37th Edaily Credit Rating Expert Survey (SRE: Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily), Lotte received 164 votes (44%) out of a total of 373 votes (197 respondents; up to two multiple responses allowed from among 12 candidates), ranking first among groups in need of restructuring. This means that four out of five respondents (83.2%) selected Lotte. Breaking it down further, credit analysts (CA) cast 52 votes, while non-credit analysts (non-CA) cast 112 votes.
Lotte also ranked first in the question asking which group had inappropriate restructuring trends or management strategies, receiving 134 votes (37.5%) out of 357. The percentage of votes for both questions increased compared to last year (43.3% and 35.8%, respectively). In the “worst ratings” category of this survey, Lotte Chemical also ranked first with 95 votes (86 of which were downgrade recommendations), reinforcing the prevailing view that the outlook for the affiliate group as a whole remains bleak.
Although Lotte Chemical returned to profitability in the first half of the year, cash outflows caused its net debt to rise to 8.8376 trillion won at the end of June—an increase of more than 1.3 trillion won compared to the end of last year. The company is expected to slip back into the red in the third quarter.
One SRE advisory committee member remarked, “Lotte has now become a regular on the list of groups requiring restructuring or deemed inappropriate.” While another committee member countered, “Hasn’t Lotte improved significantly?” the bond market’s view has actually grown more critical.
Shinsegae rose from fourth place last year to second place in both the “groups requiring restructuring” (42 votes, 11.3%) and “groups with inappropriate strategies” (61 votes, 17.1%) categories. The decision by Shinsegae and E-Mart to spend 1.271 trillion won to acquire the financial investor (FI) stake in SSG.com weighed heavily on the group’s assessment. In the merger and acquisition (M&A) section of this survey, this transaction also ranked first (28.9%) as the “M&A deal causing the most concern.” SSG.com posted a net loss of 99.7 billion won last year, with the deficit widening.
Hyosung ranked third in both questions (40 votes and 36 votes, respectively), but the number of votes citing “inappropriate strategy” fell by nearly half from 68 last year. For Doosan and Hanwha, the number of votes indicating a need for restructuring rose from 6 last year to 24 and 21, respectively, this year. Doosan is set to acquire SK Siltron in a deal valued at approximately 2.3 trillion won. The acquisition price is nearly half of Doosan Corp.’s consolidated net debt as of the end of June.
SK ranked first in the question asking which group has reasonable restructuring trends and management strategies, receiving 94 votes (25.8%) out of 365. It moved up two spots from third place (70 votes) last year. While votes from CA members (29 votes) remained the same as last year, votes from non-CA members increased from 41 to 65, driving SK to the top spot. In the ranking of groups in need of restructuring, SK fell from second place (104 votes) to fourth place (33 votes). SK Corp.’s consolidated net debt as of the end of June stood at 48.3732 trillion won, a decrease of more than 12 trillion won from a year earlier.
Samsung rose from fourth place last year to second place with 89 votes (24.4%). Hyundai Motor, which ranked first last year, slipped to third place with 58 votes (15.9%). Hyundai Motor’s vote share has fallen for two consecutive years, from 37.4% in the 35th survey to 22% last year and 15.9% this year.
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
Lotte Group has ranked first for the second consecutive year on a list of “groups in need of restructuring” compiled by bond market experts. It also ranked first in a survey asking which groups have i…
KYOCHON FOOD&BEVERAGE, operator of the Kyochon Chicken franchise, is expanding its sales channels for traditional Korean liquor by introducing its premium makgeolli, “Eunhwasu: A Night of Stargazing 1…
Google Play announced the “2026 Best of the Year” on the 18th, highlighting the apps and games that were most popular among users over the past year.
In South Korea, Nexon’s “Maple Grow” was…