Government Boosts Hostile M&As, While Pension Funds Draw the Line
[New Value-Up Measures Spark Controversy Over Hostile M&A] ①
Government Considers 'Bear Hug' Support Fund… Use of Pension Funds Also Discussed
National Pension Service Restricts Investments in Hostile M&A… Also Considering Expansion of Investments in Other Funds
Major Shareholder Ownership Barriers Persist… Standards for Takeovers and Defense Need to Be Revised
[Edaily Marketin JI YEONG-EUI YunJi Kim Reporter] Although the government has played the “hostile M&A” card to put pressure on undervalued companies, there are significant obstacles preventing a vigorous competition for management control. This is due not only to the ownership structure of domestic companies—where shares are concentrated among major shareholders, making them highly resistant to takeovers—but also to the fact that major public funds, such as the National Pension Service, generally shy away from investing in management control disputes. Observers point out that for competition over management control to fulfill its intended purpose without devolving into a war of attrition, it must be supported by institutional reforms that go beyond simply lowering the barriers to acquisition—reforms that encompass the creation of favorable investment conditions and the protection of minority shareholders.
[Edaily Reporter Kim Jeong-hoon]
According to the investment banking (IB) industry on the 18th, there are virtually no precedents of major domestic pension funds and mutual aid associations investing in funds that promote hostile M&A as a key investment strategy. In particular, when the National Pension Service signed a discretionary management agreement with MBK Partners last February, it included a condition stipulating that it would not participate in hostile M&A investments. This is the reason behind the controversy surrounding the management control dispute at Korea Zinc. At the time, the National Pension Service announced that it would consider applying similar conditions to other private equity funds (PEFs).
According to the Financial Supervisory Service, the total committed capital of domestic institutional-only private equity funds (PEFs) reached 167.5 trillion won at the end of last year. Of the 28.1 trillion won in investments executed last year, 23.7 trillion won consisted of management-participation investments, including management buyouts. Although the domestic PEF market has grown into one where management-participation investments worth tens of trillions of won are made, hostile M&A remains an unfamiliar investment area for public funds. An official from a pension fund management firm said, “Since there aren’t that many good examples domestically, there is a reputational risk,” adding, “It could be problematic if we are criticized regarding our responsibilities as investors.”
The concentration of voting rights in the hands of major shareholders is also a stumbling block. At a capital market policy roundtable chaired by the President on the 13th, it was pointed out that there are approximately 570 listed companies where the combined stake held by major shareholders and related parties exceeds 50 percent and the price-to-book ratio (PBR) is less than 1. Even a Korean-style “bear hug”—which strengthens board review and disclosure requirements for takeover bids—cannot force major shareholders to sell their stakes.
Mechanisms are also needed to prevent competition for control from escalating into protracted disputes. In 2023, Japan established guidelines for corporate takeovers, specifying criteria for boards of directors to evaluate acquisition proposals. In the United Kingdom, an acquirer who secures 30% or more of the voting rights is, in principle, obligated to launch a tender offer for all remaining shares. It has been pointed out that South Korea, too, must establish mechanisms to verify an acquirer’s financing capacity and business plans, curb unreasonable defensive measures by existing management, and simultaneously protect the interests of minority shareholders.
Although the government has played the “hostile M&A” card to put pressure on undervalued companies, there are significant obstacles preventing a vigorous competition for management control. This is du…
Samyang Round Square, the holding company of SamyangFoods(003230), has established a wind power generation subsidiary in Pyeongchang, Gangwon Province. This move is intended to pursue a “repowering” p…
With the opening of “G-STAR 2026,” Korea’s largest game exhibition, just one day away, all eyes in the gaming industry are on the event. Moving away from past exhibitions that primarily featured new t…