Finance

"We Don't Want Cloned Apple Stocks… Market Opportunities Lie in the Tokenization of Unlisted Stocks"

"Canada Grants First Full License for Issuance and Distribution of Tokenized Securities"—Kim Do-hyung, CEO of Finhaven 9 out of 10 U.S.-listed companies opposed the move… Critics say, “They tried to tokenize the wrong things” "Listed Companies Are Not Rejecting Tokenization; They Are Rejecting Solutions to Problems They Don't Understand" "Tokenizing Inefficiencies Is Reform… Tokenizing Unlisted Stocks Is the Real Opportunity"

Lee Jeong Hun
2026-11-20 10:47:43
[Edaily Reporter Lee Jeong Hun ] Nine out of ten publicly traded companies that initially planned to tokenize and trade their shares have requested that “our shares be excluded,” leaving the U.S.’s first tokenized securities exchange—set to open soon—in a half-empty state. However, some analysts suggest that the problem lies in the fact that the targets for tokenization were chosen incorrectly.

The argument is that there is nothing to be gained by replicating the U.S. stock market—already the most efficient in the world—using blockchain technology. Instead, it is pointed out that tokenizing unlisted stocks, which are highly inefficient, is where true market opportunities lie.

Kim Do-hyung, CEO of Finhaven (Photo: Reporter Lee Jeong Hun )


Kim Do-hyung, CEO of FinHaven—Canada’s first company to receive full authorization for the issuance and distribution of tokenized securities—made a provocative remark in a post on the “FinHaven Insights” blog on the 20th, stating that the attempts by these U.S. tokenized securities exchanges were “trying to tokenize the wrong thing.”

In fact, OKXICE—a 50-50 joint venture between the major cryptocurrency exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE)—released a list last month of 62 U.S. companies to be traded as tokens. However, during the 30-day objection period granted to issuers, a staggering 56 companies filed objections. Apple, NVIDIA, Microsoft, Amazon, Tesla, JPMorgan, and Coca-Cola were all excluded from the tokenization list.

The remaining companies on the original list—Strategy, Coinbase, Robinhood, Circle, Securitize, and BitGo—are all firms involved in the virtual asset sector. OKXICE plans to launch on the 23rd with these six securities, along with Better.com and 59 Direxion exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

In a post that day, CEO Kim stated, “The value created by tokenization is proportional to the inefficiencies of the market it replaces.” He argued that in markets that are already efficient, tokenization merely adds another layer of intermediaries rather than creating value.

According to CEO Kim, the U.S. stock market’s average daily trading volume last year reached approximately $1.1 trillion, an all-time high. Large-cap stocks are already settled the day after trading (T+1). The bid-ask spread for Apple and NVIDIA is less than one cent. Pre-market and after-hours trading also exist.

The only real benefits tokenization offers these companies are 24-hour trading, stablecoin settlements, and automated market makers (AMMs). From the issuer’s perspective, this isn’t a problem they wanted to solve—it’s a new risk. It’s impossible to predict how stock prices will be formed on new exchanges or how much volatility will increase. Investors might also mistakenly believe the company is endorsing the product.

Issues regarding shareholder rights, market transparency, and the offshore location of crypto partners have also been raised. There are also memories of the 2008 financial crisis. The time when the market closes overnight gives the market, the board of directors, and regulatory authorities a chance to catch their breath. A 24-hour market eliminates that breathing room.

The exchange’s design acknowledges this. The size of each token is capped at 0.25% of the underlying stock’s trading volume from the previous month. It is, in effect, a “satellite” orbiting the real market rather than a market that creates new liquidity. The current size of the tokenized stock market also illustrates this point. By mid-year, the total market was valued at between $2.4 billion and $2.8 billion. The largest tokenized NVIDIA/USDC pool on Solana amounted to only about $2.8 million. This stands in stark contrast to NVIDIA, a single stock that trades tens of billions of dollars daily on traditional markets.

CEO Kim assessed the situation, stating, “Issuers did not reject tokenization itself; they rejected a solution to a problem they did not have.”

Furthermore, CEO Kim noted that BlackRock’s BUIDL—the flagship tokenized U.S. Treasury fund—also revealed similar limitations. BUIDL surpassed $1 billion just one year after its launch in March 2024. At its peak, it approached $3 billion, becoming the flagship of institutional tokenization. However, according to RWA.xyz, BUIDL’s size stood at approximately $1.6 billion as of the 18th, having decreased by 3.24% over the past 30 days. This is about 45% lower than its peak. In March of this year, it even ceded the top spot for tokenized U.S. Treasuries to Circle’s USYC.

Observers point to the composition of its holders as the cause. Bidle’s growth was driven by capital from the crypto industry—specifically, protocols using it as reserve assets, stablecoin issuers using it as collateral for synthetic dollars, and exchanges accepting it as margin for derivatives. There were 112 holders, and the minimum investment was $5 million. This was also the case during the largest monthly outflow since its launch (approximately $447 million). The market cited redemptions by a specific class of investors and collateral flows following the inclusion of the asset as margin collateral by Deribit and Crypto.com as the causes.

CEO Kim described this as “funds seeking a parking spot to earn interest on dollars while waiting for the next trade.” Since this money is set aside for leverage, basis trading, and yield-seeking, it will leave once better collateral options emerge or the market cycle turns. He pointed out that a sustainable capital market cannot be built on top of liquidity whose purpose lies elsewhere.

There are also structural issues. Currently in the U.S., Cede & Co., acting on behalf of the Depository Trust Company (DTC), is the registered owner of virtually all listed stocks. Below that are brokers, custodians, and sub-custodians. Investor ownership lies at the very bottom of this chain. Most tokenized stocks follow this chain exactly. A third party purchases the shares, transfers them through a special purpose vehicle (SPV), and deposits them with a custodian. Tokens are issued using these shares as collateral, and the tokens are settled using a stablecoin issued by another company.

There are ten layers, ranging from the issuer to the transfer agent, DTC, Cede & Co., the broker, the custodian, the token issuer, the blockchain, the trading platform, and the stablecoin issuer. Not a single layer of the existing structure has been eliminated.

Many of these “wrapper” tokens merely provide price exposure without conferring any legal rights to shareholders. They carry no voting rights, and holders’ names do not appear on the shareholder registry. Corporate actions, such as dividend payments, are handled manually by the wrapper provider. This is why the SEC distinguished between issuer-led tokenization and third-party tokenization in a staff statement issued this past January.

CEO Kim emphasized, “Innovation is measured not by what has been added, but by what has been removed.”

Accordingly, CEO Kim identified the unlisted market—where inefficiencies are greatest—as the direction tokenization should take. The number of publicly listed U.S. companies has fallen by 38%, from 8,823 in 1996 to approximately 5,500 today. Some estimates suggest that only 14% of U.S. companies with annual revenue exceeding $100 million are publicly listed. The global private market grew to approximately $16 trillion by the end of 2024. While value creation has shifted to the private market, the infrastructure has not kept pace.

Selling a single share of unlisted stock involves a lengthy process. A buyer must be found through a broker, and the price is negotiated with virtually no public data available. After notifying the company of the transfer, one must wait through a 30- to 60-day right of first refusal (ROFR) period. Following board approval and legal review, the shareholder registry—typically managed via a spreadsheet—is updated. Forge, a platform for trading unlisted shares, states that direct transactions typically take 45 to 60 days to settle. Fees of around 5% on each side are also common. This contrasts sharply with the public market, where settlements occur within a single day.

In such markets, tokens created directly by the issuer replace multiple layers without adding any new ones. The shareholder registry becomes the ledger itself. Transfer restrictions, ROFRs, and investor eligibility requirements are encoded as code that executes automatically at the time of transfer. Settlement times are reduced from weeks to minutes, and prices begin to be established where none previously existed.

CEO Kim summarized the true purpose of tokenization as twofold: reducing settlement, counterparty, and exchange risks; and increasing efficiency by eliminating intermediaries and reducing time and costs. OKXICE’s listing is assessed as having failed to meet both of these objectives. It involved exchanges, prices, and counterparties that the issuer did not want, and it merely replicated what was already the most efficient market. He described the opposition from the 56 companies as “not a defeat for tokenization, but a correction.” He advised, “Tokenize inefficiencies, not headlines.”

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

Key Figures Behind Record Semiconductor Earnings Promoted to President… SamsungElectronics’ ‘Performance-Based’ Personnel Shuffle (Comprehensive)

SamsungElectronics(005930)has implemented a performance-based personnel reshuffle by promoting key executives who led its semiconductor business to record-breaking results this year to the position of…
2026-11-20 10:52:19

Corporation

HYUNDAI G.F. HOLDINGS, the holding company of the Hyundai Department Store Group, Added to the KOSPI 200 Index

HYUNDAIDEPARTMENTSTORECO.,LTD’s holding company, HYUNDAI G.F. HOLDINGS(005440), will be newly added to the KOSPI 200, South Korea’s leading stock index. HYUNDAI G.F. HOLDINGS CI. (Image courtesy o…
2026-11-20 10:27:24

IT·Science

ROBOTIS Signs 4 Billion Won Parts Supply Contract with Polen Robotics

ROBOTIS(108490)will supply robot actuators worth approximately 4 billion won to French robotics developer Polen Robotics. This contract covers the first batch, and additional orders are expected in th…
2026-11-20 09:07:55