Bonds·FX Policy

[37th SRE][Survey] Han Shin Rating: Frequent Rating Adjustments, but Credibility in Question… “Reluctant to Rate Stocks Held by Major Investors”

[37th SRE] Han Shin Rating Leads with 9 Proactive Adjustments… Han Ki Rating and Na Shin Rating Follow with 7 Each Nashin Rating Ranks First in Appropriateness of Proactive Opinion Presentation… Hanshin Rating Ranks Third Rating Upgrade-to-Downgrade Ratio Rises from 1.07 to 2.77… Clear Uptrend 67% of Experts Say "Current Pace of Rating Adjustments Is Appropriate"... Predictive Accuracy Also Called Into Question

KIM YEON-SEO
2026-11-17 10:30:19
[Edaily Marketin Reporter KIM YEON-SEO ] Tension is mounting in the domestic credit market following the U.S. Federal Reserve’s decision last September to raise the benchmark interest rate for the first time in three years and two months. As the burden of raising funds increases due to rising interest rates, credit trends have varied by sector. While the electrical and electronics, oil refining, and shipping sectors showed an upward trend in credit ratings and outlooks, the petrochemical sector continued its negative trend this year, following last year’s pattern.

Hankook Rating actively adjusted corporate credit ratings and outlooks this year to reflect market changes. However, market participants’ assessments differed. In a category evaluating the appropriateness of proactive recommendations, Hankook Rating received the lowest score among the three major credit rating agencies. Analysts suggest that while the frequency of rating adjustments has increased, this has not translated into the “proactiveness” perceived by the market.


Preemptive Rating Adjustments by Credit Rating Agencies: Up from 19 Last Year to 23 This Year
Edaily examined corporate bond credit ratings, credit outlooks, and and “Credit Watch” adjustments by credit rating agencies during the evaluation period—from October 1 of last year to September 30 of this year—based on investment-grade ratings (AAA–BBB-), Han Shin Rating carried out a total of 9 preemptive adjustments, recording the highest number among the three rating agencies. Korea Ratings (KRI) and NICE Credit Rating (NICE) each recorded 7 cases. For lagging adjustments, NICE and KRI each had 10 cases, while Han Shin Rating had 8.

For this survey, a “preemptive adjustment” was defined as an adjustment made more than 5 business days earlier than other rating agencies, provided the difference was within 3 months; a “follow-up adjustment” was defined as an adjustment made after such a preemptive adjustment. Differences of 5 business days or less were excluded to account for the time required for internal administrative processing at the rating agencies, and cases exceeding 3 months were not included in the preemptive or follow-up adjustment categories, as they were deemed to reflect differing perspectives on creditworthiness.

During the survey period, the credit rating agencies made a total of 23 preemptive adjustments, an increase of 4 from last year’s 19. Follow-up adjustments—made in response to preemptive adjustments by other agencies—also rose from 21 last year to 28 this year.
Han Shin Rating: Quick to Adjust Ratings, but Appropriateness of Opinions Ranks Third
Han Shin Rating took the lead in addressing issues by proactively adjusting corporate credit ratings and outlooks in a total of 9 cases. There were 2 credit rating upgrades and 2 downgrades, along with 2 upward revisions and 3 downward revisions to rating outlooks.

Hankook Rating also took a proactive approach this year in adjusting the credit ratings and outlooks of petrochemical companies, which continued to face sluggish business conditions. On June 12, it downgraded Yeocheon NCC’s credit rating from ‘A-’ to ‘BBB+’. While Lotte Chemical’s credit rating remained at “AA-,” its outlook was lowered from “Stable” to “Negative.”

Even prior to the JoongAng Ilbo’s restructuring—which sent shockwaves through the BBB-rated corporate bond market—Hankook Rating had proactively adjusted its rating outlook. On April 20, Han Shin Rating changed JoongAng Ilbo’s rating outlook to “Negative.” In contrast, Han Ki Rating and Na Shin Rating did not adjust their outlooks to “Negative” until May 15, about a month later. Subsequently, JoongAng Ilbo’s credit rating was downgraded repeatedly, ultimately falling to “D.”

In addition, Han Shin Rating proactively upgraded the credit ratings of IM Capital and K Car Capital, and also raised the rating outlooks for Kiwoom Capital and HD Construction Machinery.

Korea Ratings was found to have taken the lead among credit rating agencies, with three credit rating upgrades, three outlook upgrades, and one credit rating downgrade. It proactively upgraded SK Hynix’s credit rating from “AA” to “AA+” and, buoyed by the boom in the shipbuilding industry, raised Hanwha Ocean’s credit rating from “BBB+” to “A-” and assigned a “Positive” outlook.

Last February, NICE Credit Rating preemptively upgraded the credit ratings of S-Oil and LG Uplus from “AA” to “AA+,” respectively. It also preemptively raised Pungsan’s credit rating from “A+” to “AA-.” In addition, it preemptively adjusted the rating outlooks for HD Construction Machinery (A) and Hyosung Heavy Industries (A) from “Stable” to “Positive.”

However, the market’s assessment of the appropriateness of these preemptive opinions differed from the actual number of adjustments made. At the 37th SRE, when asked about the appropriateness of preemptive opinions by credit rating agency, NICE received the highest score of 3.67. This was followed by Korea Ratings with 3.59 and Han Shin Rating with 3.55.

An SRE advisory committee member explained, “From the perspective of institutional investors, the fact that there were few rating changes for companies in which they have substantial investments and that are well-known appears to have influenced the assessment of the appropriateness of Han Shin Rating’s preemptive opinions,” adding, “This reflects the fact that the weight assigned by the market varies from company to company.”
Credit Rating Upward-to-Downward Ratio Surges from 1.07x in the 36th Survey to 2.77x in the 37th Survey
During the survey period for the 37th SRE
,
the trend toward
credit rating
upgrades became even more pronounced. The downward trend in ratings that had continued through the 35th survey shifted to an upward trend starting with the 36th survey. The average up-to-down ratio (up-down ratio) among the three credit rating agencies stood at 2.77, more than double the 1.07 recorded at the end of September 2025. The up-to-down ratio is calculated by dividing the number of rating upgrades by the number of downgrades; a ratio above 1 indicates that there were more upgrades than downgrades.

When asked for their opinion on the current pace of rating adjustments, 132 out of 197 respondents (67.01%) answered that “the current pace of rating adjustments is appropriate.” By job category, 36 credit analysts (CA) and 96 non-credit analysts (non-CA) assessed the current pace of rating adjustments as appropriate.

Conversely, 42 respondents (21.32%) expressed the opinion that “the pace of upgrades should be slowed.” This included 18 CAs and 24 non-CAs. Fourteen respondents (7.11%) stated that “the trend should shift toward downgrades,” while only 7 respondents (3.55%) believed that “the upward trend should be expanded.”

The ratio of upgrades to downgrades, calculated excluding defaulted companies, was 3.30 to 1, which was higher than the 2.77 to 1 ratio calculated including defaulted companies. This suggests that the trend toward credit rating upgrades becomes even more pronounced when insolvent companies are excluded. In this regard, 127 out of 197 respondents (64.47%) answered that “the current pace of rating adjustments is appropriate,” indicating that even when insolvent companies are excluded, the majority of credit experts consider the current pace of rating adjustments to be appropriate.

The trend toward credit rating upgrades gained momentum last year as the number of upgrades increased, particularly in sectors showing improved performance. Rating upgrades were particularly notable in sectors such as electrical and electronics, oil refining, and shipping, which experienced favorable market conditions and improved financial performance. Conversely, in sectors where sluggish market conditions persisted—such as petrochemicals, construction, and steel—credit ratings were downgraded due to factors like declining profitability.

Credit experts pointed to the asymmetry in rating adjustments across sectors as the main reason behind the pronounced trend of credit rating upgrades. Their analysis suggests that while rating downgrades were delayed in sectors with sluggish business conditions—such as petrochemicals—due to the “Middle East boom,” ratings in sectors with improved performance were upgraded relatively quickly, resulting in a high upgrade-to-downgrade ratio.

An SRE advisory committee member stated, “It was puzzling that the ratio of upgrades to downgrades reached 2.77 times despite the perceived economic conditions not being favorable,” adding, “While it is difficult to refute given that corporate performance supports this trend, it is also not an easy result to readily accept.”

He continued, “In the industry outlooks released by credit rating agencies last year, there were far more companies with negative outlooks, but the actual results turned out to be the exact opposite.” He pointed out, “Sectors that received negative outlooks, such as petrochemicals, saw their downgrades delayed due to the Middle East boom, whereas sectors with strong business conditions were quickly upgraded. Given this asymmetry, it is necessary to review the predictive capabilities of credit rating agencies.”

[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Survey] Han Shin Rating: Frequent Rating Adjustments, but Credibility in Question… “Reluctant to Rate Stocks Held by Major Investors”

Tension is mounting in the domestic credit market following the U.S. Federal Reserve’s decision last September to raise the benchmark interest rate for the first time in three years and two months. As…
2026-11-17 10:30:19

IT·Science

Celltrion’s ‘Herzuma’ Wins Brazilian Government Tender for 7 Consecutive Years… Follow-up Products Also Set to Launch

“Herjumma,” a treatment for breast and stomach cancer. (Active ingredient: trastuzumab) (Photo: Celltrion) Celltrion(068270)has secured a large-scale supply contract for “Herjumma” (active ingredi…
2026-11-17 10:29:04