Bonds·FX Policy

[37th SRE][Worst] Long-Term Slump in Petrochemicals and Rechargeable Batteries… Top-Ranked Companies Dominate Worst Ratings List

[37th SRE] Lotte Chemical Tops Worst-Rated List with 95 Votes… LG Chem Ranks Second Credit Concerns Grow Amid Sluggish Conditions in the Petrochemical and Rechargeable Battery Sectors Calls for Credit Rating Upgrades for Meritz Financial Group, LG Electronics, and Others

KIM YEON-SEO
2026-11-18 06:30:07
[Edaily Marketin KIM YEON-SEO Reporter] Calls are growing for credit rating downgrades of major petrochemical companies due to the prolonged slump in the petrochemical industry. Amid continued poor performance across the industry due to slowing global demand and oversupply, major petrochemical companies were ranked among the top in the “Worst Ratings” list—which identifies companies with inappropriate credit ratings—in the 37th SRE. In the rechargeable battery sector as well, major companies were included in the top ranks of the “Worst Ratings” list as the industry’s slump persists.

Lotte Chemical took the top spot on the “Worst Ratings” list. Since 2022, the petrochemical market has been in a downturn due to global oversupply, and the business competitiveness of the petrochemical sector has significantly weakened compared to the past, partly due to China’s rising self-sufficiency rate. The rechargeable battery business is also continuing to post losses as market conditions deteriorate. With prospects for a medium- to long-term improvement in market conditions expected to be limited, Lotte Chemical rose from fifth place in the 36th SRE Worst-Rated list to first place this year.

LG Chem, also in the petrochemical sector, ranked second. Given the split in credit ratings—with domestic credit rating agencies assigning “AA+” and “AA0,” respectively—and the “negative” outlook on the credit rating, the prevailing view was that a downgrade was necessary. Petrochemical companies Hanwha Solutions and SK GeoCentric also tied for 7th place on the Worst Rating list due to the industry slump and deteriorating earnings.

“Worst Rating” is a metric that evaluates the appropriateness of a company’s credit rating. It is a method by which market experts who analyze and manage corporate bonds assess which credit ratings fail to properly reflect a company’s fundamentals. Launched in 2005, the Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily (SRE) has consistently highlighted the overvaluation of credit ratings assigned by credit rating agencies and has proactively warned of credit risks at major companies such as STX, Dongyang, Kumho, Woongjin, Daehan Cable, Hanjin Shipping, Hyundai Merchant Marine (HMM), and Doosan.

For a considerable period following the 2008 global financial crisis, companies with the “worst ratings” were considered to have overrated credit ratings. However, starting with the 24th SRE in 2016, the survey has also asked about the appropriateness of credit ratings and the direction of rating adjustments. Recently, the trend toward credit rating upgrades has been strengthening. The average up-to-down ratio of the three credit rating agencies, which stood at 1.07 at the end of September last year, rose to 2.77 by the end of September this year.



◇ Prolonged Downturn in the Petrochemical Industry… Lotte Chemical Takes the Unwanted Top Spot

In the 37th SRE, Lotte Chemical was named the company with the least appropriate credit rating, receiving 95 votes (48.2%) out of 197 total respondents. With the petrochemical industry continuing to face high volatility and oversupply, the company’s potential for earnings improvement in the short term is expected to be limited.

Last March, prices for energy and chemical products surged due to supply chain disruptions caused by the U.S.-Iran conflict, leading to a temporary improvement in the profitability of Lotte Chemical’s basic chemicals division. Buoyed by inventory gains and a positive lag effect—profits resulting from the time lag in using naphtha purchased at low prices before the conflict—the company recorded an operating profit (EBIT) of approximately 46 billion won in the first quarter of this year, its first such profit in 12 quarters.

However, analysts suggest it is unlikely that this improvement in performance will continue. This is because the positive lag effect may gradually disappear as naphtha purchased at high prices is used in production. Furthermore, if product prices fall, spreads narrow, or inventory losses occur as supply chains normalize, the profitability of the Basic Chemicals division could deteriorate again.

The restructuring of the domestic petrochemical industry is another variable. Lotte Chemical is pushing ahead with a restructuring centered on its naphtha cracking facilities (NCCs) in Daesan and Yeosu; as a result, these basic chemicals businesses are scheduled to be excluded from the consolidated financial statements. Although the scale of the business will shrink, improvements in the cost structure and production efficiency are expected in the medium to long term. However, analysts note that restoring stable profit-generating capacity will require prior improvements in supply and demand by resolving the regional supply glut.

In addition to Lotte Chemical, major petrochemical companies were heavily represented among the top-ranked companies in the “worst ratings” category. LG Chem ranked second with 71 votes, while Hanwha Solutions and SK GeoCentric tied for seventh place with 34 votes each. Yeocheon NCC, which ranked first last year, received 21 votes and fell to 12th place. SK Incheon Petrochemical tied for 18th place with 14 votes, while Hyosung Chemical ranked 21st with 11 votes.

Market observers have pointed out that credit rating agencies are delaying downgrades despite the structural slump in the petrochemical industry. Analysts suggest that the combination of government-led industrial restructuring and temporary earnings improvements stemming from the U.S.-Iran conflict has made it difficult to determine the appropriate timing for credit rating adjustments.

An SRE advisory committee member stated, “There are many petrochemical companies in the ‘worst-rated’ category, yet even with a ‘negative’ credit outlook, the ratings aren’t being lowered,” adding, “The timing has become ambiguous because the government launched restructuring efforts and profits suddenly improved due to the war.” He continued, “Rather than focusing on short-term factors, [credit rating agencies] should trust their own forecasting abilities, look at the underlying structure, and downgrade when necessary,” pointing out, “Government-led restructuring is merely a matter of shifting funds from one pocket to another.”

◇ Four Battery Makers in the Top 10… Lotte Group Affiliates Also Feature in Droves

Similar to the petrochemical industry, where the slump has persisted for a long time, numerous companies in the secondary battery sector also ranked high on the “worst-rated” list. Four companies—LG Energy Solution (3rd), SK On (6th), EcoPro BM (tied for 9th), and EcoPro (tied for 9th)—made it into the top 10.

LG Energy Solution, which ranked 3rd, continues to face financial strain due to large-scale capital investments. Last year, capital expenditures totaling approximately 11 trillion won were incurred, prolonging the trend of negative free cash flow. Financial stability indicators deteriorated overall, with the debt-to-equity ratio and reliance on borrowing—which stood at 86.4% and 24.1%, respectively, at the end of 2023—rising to 140.0% and 34.4%, respectively, by the end of March this year.

Lotte Group affiliates also featured heavily among the companies with the lowest credit ratings. A total of five affiliates—including Lotte Chemical (1st), Lotte Construction (10th), Lotte Shopping (13th), Lotte Hi-Mart (tied for 14th), and Lotte Corporation (16th)—were included in the top 20. This is interpreted as concerns over the group’s overall financial burden being reflected in the assessment of the appropriateness of individual affiliates’ credit ratings.

Lotte Construction’s ranking dropped from 4th in last year’s 36th SRE Worst Ratings list to 10th this year. Although its operating cash flow has recovered thanks to improved profitability, concerns about financial stability persist due to increased working capital burdens.

With accounts receivable increasing, particularly for projects nearing completion, and contract liabilities decreasing as construction progresses in the construction, housing, and plant sectors, free cash flow (FCF) for the first half of this year recorded a deficit of 690.6 billion won. Consequently, total consolidated debt as of the end of June this year stood at 3.2317 trillion won, a significant increase compared to the end of last year.

In a survey conducted at the 37th SRE asking which group “is deemed to require restructuring due to accumulated financial burdens,” Lotte Group received 164 votes, indicating significant market concerns regarding its financial soundness. This also reflects a negative view of the Lotte Group’s overall creditworthiness in assessments of the appropriateness of individual affiliates’ credit ratings.



◇Calls for Credit Rating Upgrades for Meritz Financial Holdings and LG Electronics

On the other hand, some respondents argued that current credit ratings do not adequately reflect the companies’ creditworthiness and therefore require an upward adjustment. When only the votes indicating a need for a credit rating upgrade were tallied, Meritz Financial Group ranked first with 28 votes. It was followed by LG Electronics (25 votes) and Poongsan (21 votes). All three companies received 20 or more votes in favor of an upgrade.

Korea Ratings assigns Meritz Financial Group’s unsecured corporate bonds a credit rating of “AA (Stable).” Its core subsidiaries—Meritz Fire & Marine Insurance and Meritz Securities—have been assigned “AA+” and “AA,” respectively, under the Insurance Financial Strength Rating (IFSR). In particular, Meritz Securities expanded its business foundation by securing a license for the commercial paper (short-term finance) business in September, following a one-notch upgrade of its credit rating from “AA-” to “AA” by Korea Ratings and NICE Ratings last March.

The market views this as a reflection of expectations for an upgrade in Meritz Financial Group’s credit rating, driven by the growth of the securities industry and the government’s policy of fostering the financial investment sector. An SRE advisory committee member interpreted this, stating, “Aren’t securities firms’ assets growing faster than those of banks these days?” and added, “This reflects both government policies aimed at fostering securities firms and market sentiment that Meritz, as a leading player in the securities industry, should aim for a bank-level rating (AA+).”

For LG Electronics as well, the need for a credit rating upgrade has been raised based on the diversification of its business structure and improvements in its financial structure. The company is assessed to have achieved greater business stability by shifting away from its traditional business structure centered on home appliances and expanding the share of business-to-business (B2B) operations, such as automotive components and heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC).

Financial indicators also support expectations for a rating upgrade. As of the end of March this year, the net debt-to-equity ratio stood at 8.3%, meeting Korea Ratings’ criterion for a rating upgrade—“maintaining a ratio of 10% or less.” The ratio of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) to revenue was 11.2%, exceeding the 10% threshold required for an upgrade.

◇How Are “Worst-Rated” Companies Selected?

The pool of candidates for the “Worst-Rated” list consists of 40 companies holding investment-grade ratings ranging from “AAA” to “BBB-.” Companies (or their affiliates) that received a double-digit percentage of votes in the previous survey are retained in the candidate pool to monitor trends in the appropriateness of their credit ratings. Based on this, and after gathering opinions from the advisory committee, the candidate pool is narrowed down to focus on companies that: △ have an issuance volume above a certain threshold; △ attract significant market attention; △ have experienced recent rating changes or have differing ratings among rating agencies; or △ exhibit a discrepancy between their bond yield (MIR) and credit rating.

In the SRE survey, respondents may select up to five companies from a pool of 40 candidates. For each selected company, respondents are asked to indicate the direction of the credit rating adjustment. If an upward adjustment is deemed necessary, respondents select ▲; if a downward adjustment is deemed necessary, they select ▼. For “split-rated” companies—those with differing ratings across agencies—respondents should select ▲ if they believe the higher rating is appropriate, or ▼ if they believe the lower rating is appropriate.

The 17 companies newly included in this survey are LG Electronics, Meritz Financial Group, Harim Holdings, Daewoo E&C, SK Incheon Petrochemical, Hyundai Corporation, Poongsan, Hyundai Elevator, Netmarble, Lotte Card, HL D&I, LS Mtron, Shinwon, Lotte Corporation, Parnas Hotel, Aegis Asset Management, and Boryeong LNG Terminal.



[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Worst] Long-Term Slump in Petrochemicals and Rechargeable Batteries… Top-Ranked Companies Dominate Worst Ratings List

Calls are growing for credit rating downgrades of major petrochemical companies due to the prolonged slump in the petrochemical industry. Amid continued poor performance across the industry due to slo…
2026-11-18 06:30:07

Corporation

From 9,980-won dermatological cosmetics onward… E-MART Co., Ltd. and Nobland International Inc. Accelerate Push into Ultra-Low-Priced Beauty Market

E-MART Co., Ltd.(139480)and Nobland International Inc. are accelerating their push into the low-price cosmetics market. Nobland International Inc. has expanded its product lineup beyond its traditiona…
2026-11-18 06:00:09

IT·Science

DuChemBio Co, LTD Reports 33% Increase in Sales of Dementia Diagnostic Test… Third-Quarter Revenue Reaches 11 Billion Won

DuChemBio Co.,LTD.(176750)continued its revenue growth in the third quarter, driven by increased sales of radiopharmaceuticals for the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. With the domestic launch of Eli…
2026-11-17 19:54:02