[37th SRE][Worst] LG Corp.’s ‘AA’ Rating Unconvincing… 8 out of 10 ‘Worst’ Picks See Ratings Downgraded
[37th SRE]
Ranked 20th → 3rd… Number of CA nominees: 2 → 21
Debt Rises 3.6-Fold in Three and a Half Years… Exceeds Credit Rating Agencies’ Threshold for Downgrade Review
82% Hold a Bearish View… “Following LGCHEM,LTD, Now LG Energy Solution Too”
Earnings Rebound Thanks to ESS… Financial Improvement Expected After 2027
[Edaily Marketin LEE GEON-EOM Reporter] Doubts surrounding LG Energy Solution(373220)’s “AA” credit rating have grown rapidly over the past year. As the company’s debt has ballooned due to continued factory expansions even amid the electric vehicle “chasm” (a temporary stagnation in demand), there has been a significant increase in the view that its current rating is excessive. Its ranking on the “Worst Ratings” list—which stood at a tie for 20th place last year—has jumped to 3rd this year.
The fact that the rating remains unchanged even though the company has already exceeded the downgrade review criteria set by credit rating agencies is fueling distrust. Although earnings rebounded in the third quarter due to the energy storage system (ESS) business, the market appears to be placing greater emphasis on the company’s mounting debt.
LG Energy Solution, Worst Rating Rankings: 20th → 3rd… 82% Favor Downgrade
In the 37th Edaily Credit Rating Expert Survey (SRE: Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily), LG Energy Solution ranked third on the “worst ratings” list, with 51 out of 197 bond market experts (25.9%) responding that its current rating is inappropriate. This is the third-highest number of votes, following LOTTE CHEMICAL CORPORATION (95 votes) and LGCHEM,LTD (71 votes). Looking at the details, 42 out of the 51 respondents—82.4%—said the current rating should be downgraded. Only 9 respondents (17.6%) believed an upgrade was necessary. Even when considering only the downgrade opinions, LG Energy Solution ranked third.
By job category, 19 out of 21 credit analysts (CA) believed a downgrade was necessary. Among non-credit analysts (non-CA), including bond managers, 23 out of 30 shared the same opinion. Among managers, 17 out of 22 voted for a downgrade, while among brokers and other job categories, 6 out of 8 did the same. This means that roughly one in three (33.9%) of the 62 CAs raised concerns about LG Energy Solution’s rating. By years of experience, 20 out of 64 analysts (31.3%) with 1–6 years of experience singled out LG Energy Solution, a higher proportion than those with 7 or more years of experience (23.3%).
Its ranking has jumped significantly in just one year. LG Energy Solution first appeared on the list of candidates for the “Worst Rating” at the 35th SRE; at last year’s 36th SRE, it received votes from 13 analysts (5.9%) and ranked tied for 20th. This means the number of votes it received has nearly quadrupled in a single year.
In particular, the views of the CA members have shifted significantly. Last year, only two CA members considered LG Energy Solution’s rating inappropriate, but that number rose to 21 this year. The distribution of opinions—which last year consisted of 10 votes for a downgrade and 3 for an upgrade—has also shifted further toward downgrades this year. Along with its parent company, LGCHEM,LTD (2nd place), LG Group’s chemical and battery affiliates ranked side by side at the top. An SRE advisory committee member stated, “Following LGCHEM,LG Energy Solution has also risen in the rankings,” adding, “Petrochemical and rechargeable battery companies are dominating the top ranks.”
Debt Increased 3.6-Fold in Three and a Half Years… Exceeding the Threshold for a Downgrade Review
Concerns in the bond market stemmed from
the
rapidly swelling
debt
. From 2022 through the first quarter of this year, LG Energy Solution poured 41
.
3 trillion won (on a consolidated basis) into expanding its production capacity. Although a portion was covered by capital contributions from joint venture (JV) partners, the company continued to post an annual free cash flow (FCF) deficit of around 6 trillion won, and the funding shortfall was covered by external borrowing. According to the Financial Supervisory Service’s electronic disclosure system, LG Energy Solution’s total consolidated debt rose from 8.1093 trillion won at the end of 2022 to 22.5121 trillion won at the end of last year, and further swelled to 29.1234 trillion won by the end of June this year. This represents a 3.6-fold increase in just three and a half years. During the same period, net debt increased tenfold, from 2.1713 trillion won to 21.9531 trillion won. The debt-to-equity ratio rose from 86% to 157.1%.
The increase in the first half of this year also included one-time factors. Of the 6.6113 trillion won increase in total debt during the first half, the amount resulting from actual borrowing was 2.7313 trillion won. The remainder consisted mostly of lease liabilities totaling 2.4865 trillion won and translation effects of 1.3827 trillion won due to the rising exchange rate. The lease liabilities arose from a “sale-and-leaseback” transaction in May, in which the company sold the factory building of its joint venture with Honda to Honda and then leased it back. As borrowings increased, the interest burden also grew. Interest expenses for the first half totaled 553.2 billion won, a 39.3% increase from 397.1 billion won in the same period last year.
Profitability also failed to hold up. The operating loss for the first half was 94.4 billion won; excluding the 738.6 billion won in U.S. Advanced Manufacturing Production Tax Credit (AMPC), the deficit expands to the 800 billion won range. Compounded by a 482.1 billion won impairment loss on assets held for sale pursuant to the agreement with Honda and foreign exchange-related losses, the net loss for the first half reached 1.2727 trillion won.
The problem is that the company has already exceeded the downgrade review criteria set by credit rating agencies. NICEHoldings cited factors such as a consolidated debt-to-equity ratio expected to remain at or above 120% as grounds for a potential downgrade; as of the end of June, the ratio stood at 157.1%. NICEHoldings itself stated that the company met the criteria for a downgrade review as of the end of the first quarter.
The ratio of net debt to adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA)—which Korea Ratings Corporation cited as a factor for a potential downgrade—also exceeded 3.5 times on an annual basis, having already surpassed that threshold last year at 3.7 times. Nevertheless, both KCA and NICE maintained LG Energy Solution’s rating at “AA (Stable)” in their regular assessments last June. With the rating maintained despite exceeding the thresholds, the view is gaining traction in the bond market that LG Energy Solution’s rating is higher than its actual creditworthiness.
Earnings Rebound Thanks to ESS… Financial Improvement Expected After 2027
Earnings are showing signs of a rebound. In the preliminary third-quarter results announced by LG Energy Solution on the 8th of last month—during the survey period—revenue reached a quarterly record, rising 59% year-over-year, while operating profit increased by 25.7%. Even excluding the 416.9 billion won from AMPC, the company posted an operating profit of 339.1 billion won.
However, analysts suggest that this earnings rebound is unlikely to immediately translate into an improvement in the company’s financial structure. Cumulative operating profit for January through September stood at 661.6 billion won, a 54.9% decrease compared to the same period last year. The electric vehicle (EV) battery division continues to underperform. Korea Ratings estimated that this year’s EV battery shipment volume will drop to about half of last year’s level. Additionally, large-scale order contracts with companies such as Ford were terminated late last year.
The “Worst Rating” survey—one of the categories in E-Daily’s SRE—is a poll that gauges the market’s view on the appropriateness of credit ratings assigned by domestic credit rating agencies. To ensure the fairness of the survey analysis, E-Daily has requested rebuttal statements in a “Speakers’ Corner” format from companies (or their affiliates) that received the highest scores in the Worst Rating survey. The following is the full text of LG Energy Solution’s statement for the 37th SRE.
LG Energy Solution: “Expanding ESS Orders… Debt to Decrease Next Year and Financial Soundness to Improve”
LG Energy Solution reported third-quarter revenue of 9.6434 trillion won, a 28% increase from the previous quarter, driven by rising shipments of ESS batteries in North America and pouch and cylindrical EV batteries in Europe. The company posted an operating profit of 756 billion won (operating profit margin of 7.8%), driven by improved utilization rates at its European plants, continued supply of cylindrical products, and the inclusion of compensation from customers for productivity improvements at its new ESS mass-production plant. In the fourth quarter, revenue is expected to grow by approximately 10% quarter-over-quarter, driven by ESS revenue growth and the resumption of operations at the GM joint venture. In the ESS business, the company is expanding its presence in the AI data center market by securing additional projects from existing utility grid customers and, for the first time, signing a direct supply contract for battery energy storage systems (BESS) with a major tech company.
As of the end of the third quarter, the company secured an ESS order backlog of approximately 160 GWh, and based on current planned ESS production capacity in North America, the majority of volume through 2028 has been confirmed. The company plans to increase its North American ESS production capacity to over 50 GWh by the end of this year and to 70 GWh by the end of next year. For EV batteries, the company is also in discussions for additional orders, focusing on mid-to-low-end products and the cylindrical 46 Series. As large-scale capital expenditures are entering their final stages, the company plans to focus future spending solely on essential investments for future growth. It intends to prioritize using cash generated from operating activities to fund these investments and borrow externally only to a limited extent to cover any shortfalls, thereby gradually reducing debt. Next year, the company expects debt to decrease and financial soundness to improve as operating cash flow expands due to volume-driven growth and the burden of investment costs eases.
[This article was published in the 37th edition of the SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
Doubts surrounding LG Energy Solution(373220)’s “AA” credit rating have grown rapidly over the past year. As the company’s debt has ballooned due to continued factory expansions even amid the electric…
“It’s because AI itself doesn’t know when it’s wrong.”Park Woong-yang, CEO of GENINUS Inc. and Director of the Genomics Research Institute at Samsung Seoul Hospital, explained the reason for combining…
DuChemBio Co.,LTD.(176750)continued its revenue growth in the third quarter, driven by increased sales of radiopharmaceuticals for the diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease. With the domestic launch of Eli…