Financing

[37th SRE][Survey] Credit Rating Agencies’ Trust Rating Remains in the “4s” for Fourth Consecutive Year… Individual Agencies Show “Stagnation”

[37th SRE] Has remained in the 4-point range for the fourth consecutive year since the 34th edition Korea Ratings Regains Sole First Place… Han Shin Rating, Previously Tied for First, Plummets to Last Place Maintains 2nd Place in NICE Credit Rating… Gap in Overall and Individual Creditworthiness Scores at 0.22 Points Outlook Satisfaction Rated 3.62…Highest in Five Years

LEE GEON-EOM
2026-11-17 08:00:06
[Edaily Marketin, Reporter LEE GEON-EOM ] The credibility of domestic credit rating agencies has remained in the 4-point range for four consecutive years. Since first exceeding 4 points in the 34th Edaily Credit Rating Expert Survey (SRE: Survey of Credit Rating by Edaily) in 2023, the agencies have maintained a score in the 4-point range, reaffirming the solid trust in the credit rating system.

However, the trust levels in individual credit rating agencies have stagnated or declined, causing the gap between them and the overall trust level to widen. Korea Ratings (KRI) regained its position as the sole leader, while Korea Credit Rating (KCR), which tied for first place last year, dropped to third place. NICE Credit Rating (NICE) was the only one of the three agencies to maintain its score, rising to second place.

E-Daily conducted the 37th SRE from October 6 to 16, surveying corporate bond experts at securities firms, asset management companies, banks, insurance companies, pension funds, and mutual aid associations. There were 197 valid respondents, excluding those with one year or less of experience in corporate bond operations. This year, the upward and downward rating ratios were divided into two categories based on whether defaults were included in the assessment.

Trust Rating in the 4s for the Fourth Consecutive Year
Domestic bond market experts continued to express high trust in credit rating agencies in the 37th SRE. Survey participants rated their trust in the credit ratings issued by the three major domestic credit rating agencies—Korea Ratings, Han Shin Rating, and Na Shin Rating—at 4.00 out of 5. Although this was 0.02 points lower than the all-time high recorded in the previous survey (4.02 points), it has remained in the 4-point range for four consecutive years since the 34th survey (4.01 points).

Trust in credit ratings rose from 3.75 in the 30th survey to 3.79 in the 31st and 3.93 in the 32nd, before dipping to 3.87 in the 33rd survey due to the fallout from the 2022 Legoland incident. Since first reaching the 4.0 range in the 34th survey, it has maintained a stable trend, scoring 4.00 in the 35th, 4.02 in the 36th, and 4.00 in the 37th.

An SRE advisory committee member stated, “Maintaining a score in the 4.0 range means the credit rating system is functioning reasonably well,” adding, “The key question is whether this trend will solidify and spread to the point of disrupting the market; however, since the corporate bond market itself is distorted—with only high-quality companies remaining—it is still difficult to judge.”

There are also views that high reliability ratings cannot be viewed as entirely positive. One SRE advisory committee member said, “Reliability ratings must be interpreted in conjunction with the upward and downward adjustment ratios,” adding, “High reliability ratings themselves can send the wrong signal to credit rating agencies.”

Gap Between Overall and Individual Creditworthiness Widens
By job function, the 62 credit analysts (CAs) assigned a score of 4.16, up from the previous survey (4.13). The 135 non-credit analysts (non-CA), including bond managers and brokers, gave a score of 3.93, down 0.04 points from the previous year (3.97). Among them, managers (97 respondents) gave a score of 3.91, while other groups—including brokers and pension fund managers—gave a score of 3.97, both lower than in the previous survey (3.95 and 4.00, respectively). Respondents who rely on credit rating agency data for more than 61% of their work (107 respondents) and those whose corporate bond-related work accounts for more than 61% of their duties (66 respondents) both scored 4.02 points, exceeding the overall trust rating.

In terms of rating reliability by agency, Korea Ratings took the top spot with 3.78 points, followed by NICE Ratings (3.75 points) and Han Shin Ratings (3.74 points). However, the scores for all three agencies either stagnated or declined. Korea Ratings saw its score drop by 0.05 points from the previous survey (3.83 points), marking its lowest score since the 30th survey. Korea Credit Rating Agency fell by 0.09 points from 3.83 points, recording the largest decline among the three agencies. Following the fallout from the Legoland incident, which had pushed its score down to 3.67 in the 33rd survey, its three-year streak of consecutive increases came to an end. Analysts attribute the decline in scores for Han Ki-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong to the burden caused by the successive defaults of JR Global REIT and affiliates of the Joongang Group.

In contrast, Na Shin-pyeong maintained its score and rose to second place for the first time in three years since the 34th survey. The point difference between first and third place narrowed to 0.04 points—half that of the previous survey (0.08 points)—marking the smallest gap since the 30th survey.

Survey participants highlighted the strengths and weaknesses of each rating agency. One respondent commented, “Han Ki-pyeong produces excellent-quality rating reports but is somewhat slow in issuing ratings; Na Shin-pyeong excels at proactive evaluations but its rating rationale is somewhat lacking,” adding, “Han Shin-pyeong produces excellent reports but lacks distinctiveness in its ratings.” Na Shin-Pyeong received the highest scores among the three agencies in the categories of quality improvement efforts (3.76 points) and proactive opinion provision (3.67 points).

SRE advisory committee members noted that the gap between overall credibility and the credibility of individual credit rating agencies has widened further. The difference between overall credibility (4.00 points) and the top-ranked Han Ki-pyeong (3.78 points) was 0.22 points, widening for the second consecutive year and marking the largest gap since the 30th evaluation. Unlike the 30th, 31st, and 33rd surveys—where the top-ranked agency exceeded the overall trust score—all three agencies have fallen short of the overall trust score for the fourth consecutive year since the 34th survey. Analysts suggest that while trust in the credit rating system as a whole remains strong, the ability to distinguish between individual agencies has weakened.

Some respondents also expressed the view that “since the credit ratings from all three agencies are the same, there is no basis for differentiating their credibility.” An SRE advisory committee member stated, “There is confidence that the Key Monitoring Indicator (KMI) is moving along a predictable path aligned with financial fundamentals, and the three agencies have largely aligned their approaches.”

Among the rating agencies whose reports are used most frequently, Korea Ratings (KR) received 68 votes (34.5%), surpassing NICE Ratings (59 votes, 29.9%), which ranked first last year, while Korea Credit Rating (KCR) received 51 votes (25.9%). Satisfaction with rating reports also ranked in the order of Han Ki-pyeong (3.85 points), Na Shin-pyeong (3.81 points), and Han Shin-pyeong (3.79 points).

Outlook Satisfaction at a Five-Year High
In terms of seminar satisfaction, Na Shin-pyeong ranked first for the third consecutive year, receiving 27 votes (33.8%) out of a total of 80 respondents (excluding those with an attendance rate of less than 20%). This was followed by Han Shin-pyeong (21 votes, 26.3%) and Han Ki-pyeong (14 votes, 17.5%). In terms of research report satisfaction, Han Shin Rating took first place with 62 votes (31.5%), followed by Na Shin Rating (56 votes, 28.4%) and Han Ki Rating (33 votes, 16.8%).

Satisfaction with the “Credit Outlook” and “Credit Watch” systems—which are used as supplementary indicators alongside credit ratings—rose slightly to 3.62 out of 5 points, up from the previous survey (3.61 points), marking the second consecutive year of improvement. This is the highest level in five years, since the 32nd survey (3.65 points). The “trigger” system, which specifies the conditions for rating changes, scored 3.79 points, down 0.04 points from the previous survey (3.83 points).

By respondent category, CAs gave the “Outlook” a higher score of 3.69 points than non-CAs (3.59 points). Among non-CAs, managers and others rated it 3.64 points and 3.47 points, respectively. For “Triggers,” CAs and non-CAs scored 3.71 points and 3.82 points, respectively. Managers scored 3.88, while other staff scored 3.68.

Analysts attribute the rise in Outlook satisfaction largely to the accelerated pace of rating upgrades. An SRE advisory board member stated, “As the pace of upgrades has quickened, the time between issuing a positive outlook and actually raising the rating has shortened, which in turn has reduced the duration spent in the ‘Outlook’ category.”

However, the disparity in the speed of upgrades and downgrades was identified as a challenge. It was pointed out that while downgrades still take about one to one and a half years, upgrades are implemented immediately once the criteria are met. One SRE advisory committee member noted, “Credit rating agencies frequently move the goalposts,” adding, “When indicators deteriorate, they change their evaluation methods and adjust the trigger criteria generously to align with the resulting numbers.” He added, “We need to evaluate how often the goalposts have been moved using statistics.”
Ratio of Upgrades to Downgrades
Soars…
“Exclusion from Default” Criteria Applied in Parallel
This year,
the ratio
of investment-grade upgrades to downgrades among the three credit rating agencies has surged significantly. The ratio, which stood at 1.07 at the end of September last year, rose to 2.77 by the end of September this year. This means the number of companies whose credit ratings were upgraded was nearly three times that of those whose ratings were downgraded. Following 0.53 in 2023 and 0.97 in 2024, this marks the third consecutive year of growth.

Starting with this year’s SRE, respondents were also asked for their opinions on the upgrade-to-downgrade ratio excluding companies in default. Previously, the simple average of the three agencies’ figures had been based on mixed criteria: Korea Ratings and NICE Ratings calculated figures excluding defaults, while Hanwha Ratings included defaults in its calculations. This year, an unusual situation arose where all three agencies experienced defaults among investment-grade companies due to the bankruptcies of JR Global REITs and the Joongang Group. Some respondents also noted that the timing of responses to defaults varied by rating agency. If defaults are excluded, the upward and downward adjustment ratios for all three agencies rise to 3.30 times.

In response, 132 out of 197 respondents (67%) answered that “the current pace of rating adjustments is appropriate.” Forty-two respondents (21.3%) said “the pace of upgrades should be slowed,” 14 (7.1%) said “the trend should shift toward downgrades,” and only 7 (3.6%) said “the upward trend should be further expanded.” When excluding defaults from the criteria, the number of respondents who answered “appropriate” decreased to 127 (64.5%), while those who said “the pace of upgrades should be slowed” increased to 46 (23.4%). The proportion of “appropriate” responses fell by 10 percentage points compared to the previous survey (77%).

While this is partly due to the addition of the new option “the pace of upgrades should be slowed” this year, it is also interpreted as a sign of growing caution regarding the pace of upgrades. Notably, among CA respondents, 18 out of 62 (29%) said the pace of upgrades should be slowed, and this figure rose to 22 (35.5%) when excluding defaults.

An SRE advisory committee member analyzed, “At the end of last year, there were far more companies with negative outlooks, but the actual results were completely reversed,” adding, “In sectors with negative outlooks, such as petrochemicals, downgrades were delayed due to the Middle East boom, while sectors with strong business conditions saw rapid upgrades—this asymmetry caused the rating spread to widen significantly.” He continued, “The issue of credit rating agencies’ predictive accuracy needs to be addressed.”

There was also analysis suggesting that “survivor bias” was at play, as corporate bond issuance declined, leaving only companies likely to see their ratings rise active in the market. Nevertheless, the analysis suggests that market conditions influenced the majority of respondents’ view that the current level is appropriate. An SRE advisory committee member remarked, “Interest rates have been rising steadily, which has taken a heavy toll on the bond market; if credit ratings had moved in the opposite direction as well, the situation would have been much more difficult.” He added, “Since credit ratings are the only thing investors can rely on, they viewed the upgrade-to-downgrade ratio positively.”

[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Survey] Korea Ratings, Ranked No. 1 in Trustworthiness for the Fifth Consecutive Year

Korea Ratings & Investment Services (KRIS) ranked first (3.78 points) in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category at the 37th SRE. This marks the fifth consecutive time—since the 33rd SRE—that KRIS ha…
2026-11-17 08:15:04

Corporation

[Exclusive] Company Hints at Legal Battle with Largest Shareholder… Key Issue: Abolition of Supermajority Voting [OSCOTEC Inc. Dispute, Part 2]

September 22. With the Chuseok holiday just two days away, many people were buzzing with anticipation for the long weekend. However, the largest shareholder, standing in the public service office of t…
2026-11-17 08:01:02

IT·Science

HyundaiAutoever Named “Outstanding Honorary Company” for Shared Growth

Hyundai AutoEver ( HyundaiAutoever(307950)) announced on the 17th that it has been selected as a “Top Honorary Company” after receiving the highest rating for the third consecutive year in the “2026 S…
2026-11-17 07:55:28