[37th SRE][Survey] Korea Ratings, Ranked No. 1 in Trustworthiness for the Fifth Consecutive Year
[37th SRE]
Korea Ratings, Ranked No. 1 in Credit Rating Reliability for the Fifth Consecutive Time
Highly Rated by Securities Firms’ CA… Senior Staff Also Give High Scores
[Edaily Marketin, Reporter KIM YEON-SEO ]Korea Ratings & Investment Services (KRIS) ranked first (3.78 points) in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category at the 37th SRE. This marks the fifth consecutive time—since the 33rd SRE—that KRIS has achieved the top spot in reliability. Notably, credit analysts (CAs) at securities firms awarded scores in the 4-point range, reflecting high praise, and respondents with over seven years of experience also rated KRIS more highly than other credit rating agencies.
In the 37th SRE, Han Ki-pyeong maintained its top position for the fifth consecutive time, recording a credit rating reliability score of 3.78 (on a 5-point scale). This score represents a slight decrease from the 3.83 points recorded in the 36th SRE. The gap widened slightly compared to Korea Credit Rating (KCR), which tied for first place last year with a credit rating reliability score of 3.83. This year, the difference between first-place KRA and second-place KCR was just 0.04 points.
Korea Ratings had held the top spot in credit rating reliability for six consecutive surveys—from the 26th to the 31st—before ceding the top position to Korea Credit Rating in the 32nd survey. After regaining the top spot one year later with a reliability score nearing 4 points, it has now defended that position for five consecutive surveys.
One SRE respondent commented, “While KRA may appear to be slightly behind in terms of the speed of rating adjustments, it tends to make rating changes only after conducting careful and in-depth analysis,” adding, “This approach has built its credibility.”
A detailed look at the survey results shows that CA awarded Han Ki-pyeong a score of 3.98. This is slightly lower than the scores given to Han Shin-pyeong (4.00) and Na Shin-pyeong (4.00). In contrast, among non-CA respondents, Han Ki-pyeong received a score of 3.69, which was higher than Han Shin-pyeong (3.61) and Na Shin-pyeong (3.63). Bond managers, who make up the largest segment of non-CA respondents, gave Han Ki-pyeong a score of 3.79.
When CA respondents were divided into securities firm CAs (20) and asset management firm CAs (32), the results differed. Securities firm CAs awarded Han Ki-pyeong a score of 4.15, while asset management firm CAs awarded it 3.94. Securities firm CAs rated Han Shin-pyeong’s credit ratings as the most reliable, giving it 3.95 points, while they gave Han Shin-pyeong 3.95 points and Na Shin-pyeong 3.90 points. In contrast, asset management firm CAs ranked the agencies in the following order: Na Shin-pyeong (4.09 points), Han Shin-pyeong (3.97 points), and Han Ki-pyeong (3.94 points).
When broken down by years of experience, respondents with longer careers tended to prefer Han Ki-pyeong over the other credit rating agencies. Respondents with 7 or more years of experience gave Han Ki-pyeong a score of 3.76, the highest rating among the three agencies. Respondents with seven or more years of experience gave Han Shin Rating a score of 3.69 and Na Shin Rating a score of 3.68—both in the 3.6 range—while they gave Han Ki Rating a score in the 3.7 range.
In contrast, respondents with 1 to 6 years of experience gave Han Ki-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong 3.83 points each, while giving Na Shin-pyeong 3.89 points, rating Na Shin-pyeong’s credibility the highest. Narrowing the scope to those with 1 to 3 years of experience, Han Ki-pyeong scored 3.90, while Na Shin-pyeong scored the highest at 3.93 and Han Shin-pyeong scored the lowest at 3.83.
As in the previous year, Han Ki-pyeong received low ratings for seminar satisfaction. In the seminar satisfaction survey (excluding those with an attendance rate of 20% or less; 80 respondents), Han Ki-pyeong received only 14 votes, ranking last among the three credit rating agencies. It also received the fewest votes for research report satisfaction, garnering only 33 votes out of a total of 197 respondents.
An SRE advisory committee member stated, “While Han Ki-pyeong’s biggest mistake this year was its assessment regarding the default of JR Global REIT, the fact that institutional investors had almost no exposure to it means that the rating reliability assessment for Han Ki-pyeong can be viewed as favorable.”
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
Korea Ratings & Investment Services (KRIS) ranked first (3.78 points) in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category at the 37th SRE. This marks the fifth consecutive time—since the 33rd SRE—that KRIS ha…
September 22. With the Chuseok holiday just two days away, many people were buzzing with anticipation for the long weekend. However, the largest shareholder, standing in the public service office of t…
SamsungElectronics(005930)has added a “Galaxy XR” hands-on experience to its school-visit AI education program, “Galaxy AI Class.” This allows students to learn about multimodal AI by conversing with …