[E-Daily Reporter Kim Jinsoo ] September 22. With the Chuseok holiday just two days away, many people were buzzing with anticipation for the long weekend. However, the largest shareholder, standing in the public service office of the Suwon District Court’s Seongnam Branch annex, felt conflicted. He decided he could no longer stand by and watch the current situation unfold—he had to take action himself. There was a reason he was going to such lengths.
(Photo: Provided by the individual, AI-generated) Earlier, on July 22 of this year, the largest shareholder held discussions with the board of directors and management. During the conversation, when asked how the company would respond if it lost the appellate trial regarding the supermajority voting system, management replied, “Of course, we’ll file a petition for review.” The company had lost the first-instance trial of the “lawsuit seeking confirmation of the invalidity of the shareholders’ meeting resolution” filed by the Minority Shareholders’ Alliance and had appealed to the second instance. With the conflict among shareholders already deepening, it became clear that proceeding to a third-instance trial could deal an irreversible blow to the company.
About three weeks later, on August 10, the legal representative of the largest shareholder sent a certified letter to management requesting that a motion to withdraw the appeal against the first-instance ruling and settle the dispute be formally submitted to and deliberated upon by the board of directors. However, management responded with a reply that raised suspicions of an intent to delay the process, demanding, “Please confirm again whether this was sent on behalf of the largest shareholder or in the representative’s own name.” Subsequently, the company replied that “whether to maintain or withdraw this lawsuit is a matter for the board of directors to decide independently.”
That same month, shareholders who had reached their limit gathered. “It seems the board of directors has no will to change. We ask that the largest shareholder step forward personally.” They officially conveyed their request to the son of the largest shareholder and founder, asking him to take direct action.
September 17. The largest shareholder requested that management convene an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders. On the 21st of the same month, a board meeting was held at the request of an outside director, and a motion to withdraw the appeal was put on the agenda; however, the chairman did not put it to a vote, and the resolution failed.
September 22. With no response from the company regarding the request to convene the meeting, the largest shareholder ultimately decided to seek the court’s intervention. The largest shareholder filed an application with the court for permission to convene an extraordinary general meeting of shareholders.
The Key to Deleting the Supermajority Voting Requirement Lies in “Article 27, Paragraph 5”
Kim Seong-yeon OSCOTEC Inc.(039200) The largest shareholder and a director of Genosco proposed the following agenda items for the extraordinary general meeting: “Deletion of
Article 27
, Paragraphs 2–4 and Paragraph 5 of the Articles of Incorporation,” “Election of three directors,” and “Election of one auditor.”
Of particular note in these agenda items is the order in which they are listed. Director Kim listed “The Proposal to Delete (Abolish) Article 27, Paragraph 5 of the Articles of Incorporation” as the first agenda item for the extraordinary general meeting. The reason Director Kim placed this item first is clear: it is the provision that must be deleted first in order to abolish the supermajority voting system.
However, there are two potential legal disputes here. First, is it possible to delete Article 27, Paragraph 5 without 80% approval? Second, does the deletion of Article 27, Paragraph 5 take effect immediately upon the decision to delete it?
Article 27, Paragraph 5 of the Articles of Incorporation states: “Even when resolving to amend the provisions of Paragraphs 2, 3, and 4 of these Articles of Incorporation, the approval of at least four-fifths of the total issued shares is required.” This provision follows the provisions in Paragraphs 2 through 4, which state that “the appointment and removal of directors shall require the approval of at least four-fifths of the total issued shares”; thus, it implies that a four-fifths majority is required not only for the appointment and removal of directors but also for any amendment to these provisions.
However, a loophole in Paragraph 5 is that it does not explicitly address the amendment or deletion of Paragraph 5 itself. Director Kim exploited this loophole, arguing that the deletion of Paragraph 5 does not require an 80 percent majority of the total issued shares.
Furthermore, there remains room for differing legal interpretations regarding when the deletion of Article 27, Paragraph 5, takes effect. Only if Agenda Item No. 1 is deleted can Director Kim delete the remaining Paragraphs 2 through 4 without being subject to the 80 percent approval requirement.
Consequently, Director Kim argues that the provision ceases to be effective the moment Proposal No. 1 is passed. On the other hand, the OSCOTEC Inc. Board of Directors maintains that even if Proposal No. 1 is passed, it cannot affect the other proposals submitted alongside it.
Nevertheless, OSCOTEC Inc. has moved to persuade Director Kim. According to Director Kim, a certain executive director at OSCOTEC Inc. approached him, stating, “Opinions are divided on how to legally interpret Article 27, Paragraph 5 of the Articles of Incorporation.” This effectively hinted at a potential legal battle to Director Kim. In fact, according to Director Kim, OSCOTEC Inc. has recently shown signs of preparing for a legal response, such as retaining a law firm.
Director Kim stated, “Currently, the board maintains the position that the abolition of the supermajority voting system is a matter for shareholders to decide in accordance with relevant laws and the Articles of Incorporation; however, judging by their actual actions, it appears they have no intention of abolishing it. If management applies the weighted requirements to the motion to delete Paragraph 5 at this extraordinary general meeting of shareholders, it will become clear that the board’s words and actions are at odds.”
He continued, “While we are currently moderating our response out of consideration for our relationship with the company, if the company actually applies the weighted requirements to block candidates from joining the board, we will have no choice but to respond more forcefully. Should such a situation arise, we will mobilize every possible means and method.”
Meanwhile, OSCOTEC Inc. stated, “Director Kim Seong-yeon has declared that even if she disposes of her shares in the future, she will not receive more favorable terms than other shareholders. We welcome this, as it aligns with the principle of protecting all shareholders that OSCOTEC Inc. has consistently emphasized, and on this premise, we support the abolition of the supermajority voting system. This is because the supermajority voting system is not a mechanism to protect management, but a safeguard for all shareholders.”
Korea Ratings & Investment Services (KRIS) ranked first (3.78 points) in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category at the 37th SRE. This marks the fifth consecutive time—since the 33rd SRE—that KRIS ha…
September 22. With the Chuseok holiday just two days away, many people were buzzing with anticipation for the long weekend. However, the largest shareholder, standing in the public service office of t…
Hyundai AutoEver ( HyundaiAutoever(307950)) announced on the 17th that it has been selected as a “Top Honorary Company” after receiving the highest rating for the third consecutive year in the “2026 S…