[37th SRE][Survey] NICE Credit Rating, “One Step Ahead,” Ranks Second in Trustworthiness for the First Time in Three Years
[37th SRE]
Confidence in CA Remains Strong… Managers Lag Slightly
Just 0.03 points behind No. 1 Han Ki-pyeong… Lowest since the 30th edition
Ranked First Among Three Companies for Proactive Feedback and Quality Improvement Efforts
Junior Employees Showing Strength… Building Trust Among Long-Tenured Employees (7+ Years) Remains a ‘Challenge’
[Edaily Marketin Reporter LEE GEON-EOM ] NICE Credit Rating (NICE) ranked second in the credit rating reliability category of the 37th Edaily Survey of Credit Rating Experts (SRE). It was the only one of the three major credit rating agencies to maintain its score, rising to second place for the first time in three years since the 34th survey. However, its reliability rating among the group with over seven years of experience remained the lowest among the three agencies, leaving this as an area for improvement.
In the 37th SRE, NICE Credit Rating scored 3.75 points (on a 5-point scale) for credit rating reliability, placing second behind Korea Corporate Rating (KCR, 3.78 points). It was just 0.01 points ahead of Korea Credit Rating (KCR, 3.74 points), which ranked third.
The point difference from the top-ranked agency was 0.03 points, narrowing from 0.13 points in the 35th SRE and 0.08 points in the 36th SRE, marking the smallest gap since the 30th SRE. After scoring 3.69 points in the 33rd SRE, NICE Credit Rating steadily improved its score to 3.72 points in the 34th, 3.73 points in the 35th, and 3.75 points in the 36th, and maintained the same score this year. Looking at the details, Nara Credit Rating received higher support from credit analysts (CAs) than from non-credit analysts (non-CAs), including bond managers. CAs awarded Nara Credit Rating a score of 4.00, tying it with Han Credit Rating (4.00) for the highest score. This is 0.02 points higher than Han Credit Rating (3.98 points).
The CA score, which was the lowest among the three agencies last year at 3.76 points, rose by 0.24 points. In contrast, non-CAs awarded a score of 3.63 points, trailing Han Ki-pyeong (3.69 points). In particular, bond managers gave Na Shinpyeong a score of 3.64 points, which was lower than Han Ki-pyeong (3.68 points) and Han Shinpyeong (3.65 points). Other job categories, such as bond brokers—which had given the highest score last year at 3.91 points—also lowered their rating this year to 3.61 points, a decrease of 0.30 points.
By years of experience, trust levels were highest among junior and mid-level practitioners. Na Shin-pyeong received a score of 3.89 from employees with 1–6 years of experience (64 people), which was 0.06 points higher than Han Ki-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong (3.83 points each). Among those with 1–3 years of experience (41 respondents), it also led with a score of 3.93, ahead of Han Ki Rating (3.90) and Han Shin Rating (3.83). By institution, securities firm credit analysts and asset management firm credit analysts awarded Na Shin Rating scores of 3.90 and 4.09, respectively. The score from asset management firm credit analysts was the highest among the three agencies.
Nara Credit Rating also received the highest scores among the three firms in the categories of quality improvement efforts (3.76 points) and proactive feedback (3.67 points). In particular, the CA awarded Nara Credit Rating 4.18 points and 4.15 points, respectively, for these two categories. In terms of seminar satisfaction, it maintained its top ranking for the third consecutive year, receiving votes from 27 out of 80 participants (excluding those with an attendance rate of less than 20%), or 33.8%.
One SRE advisory committee member stated, “There is a general consensus that efforts to improve quality are a recognized strength of Na Shin-pyeong,” adding, “However, the absolute score has dropped slightly compared to last year.” Another advisory committee member noted, “When Na Shin-pyeong was the first to downgrade Lotte’s credit rating, it faced significant criticism and received poor evaluations,” but added, “In hindsight, it has begun to receive recognition for making the right decision.”
Some analysts suggest that NICE Credit Rating benefited this year because it does not hold a valid rating for JR Global REIT. Although NICE Credit Rating successfully defended its score, its failure to gain sufficient trust from senior-level practitioners remains a drawback. NICE Credit Rating received a score of 3.68 from the group of senior practitioners with over seven years of experience (133 people), which was lower than that of Korea Ratings (3.76) and Han Shin Rating (3.69).
An SRE advisory committee member stated, “Since they entered the market as a latecomer, they still carry an image similar to that of NICE Credit Information, so those with long tenures tend not to trust them fully.” Among survey participants, there was also the opinion that “while NICE Credit Rating leads in terms of the degree of improvement, Han Ki-pyeong and Han Shin-pyeong still lead in absolute terms.” It was also pointed out that there are relatively many cases where, after adjusting the rating outlook, a ‘stable’ outlook is reassigned without any change in the actual rating.
[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]
NICE Credit Rating (NICE) ranked second in the credit rating reliability category of the 37th Edaily Survey of Credit Rating Experts (SRE). It was the only one of the three major credit rating agencie…
September 22. With the Chuseok holiday just two days away, many people were buzzing with anticipation for the long weekend. However, the largest shareholder, standing in the public service office of t…
SamsungElectronics(005930)has added a “Galaxy XR” hands-on experience to its school-visit AI education program, “Galaxy AI Class.” This allows students to learn about multimodal AI by conversing with …