Issues & Trends

[37th SRE][Survey] Han Shin Rating Ranks Last Across All Categories, from Credibility to Reports

[37th SRE] Rating and Reliability: Rank Drops from Joint 1st to 3rd Place Ranked 3rd in Pre-Market Opinions, Evaluation Reports, and Quality Improvement Ranked No. 1 in Research Report Satisfaction

Hur Jieun
2026-11-17 09:00:07
[Edaily Marketin Hur Jieun Reporter] Korea Ratings plummeted to third place—the lowest ranking—in the “Credit Rating Reliability” category of the 37th SRE. In addition to rating reliability, Korea Ratings ranked third in all four categories used to evaluate individual credit rating agencies: proactive opinion provision, satisfaction with rating reports, and quality improvement efforts. Having suffered a major blow to its credibility following the Legoland incident, Korea Ratings redoubled its efforts and tied for first place with Korea Ratings & Investment with a score of 3.83 at the 36th SRE last year; however, this year it recorded its lowest ranking with a score of 3.74.


The 197 bond market experts who participated in the 37th SRE rated Hanshin Credit Rating’s credit rating reliability at 3.74 points (out of 5). By profession, the group of 62 credit analysts (CAs) gave Hanshin Credit Rating a score of 4.0, tying it with Naisin Credit Rating (4.00) for the highest score. However, the 135 non-CA participants gave a lower score of 3.61, dragging down the overall average. An SRE advisory committee member analyzed, “There were issues with Han Shin Rating’s response to the Lego Land incident,” adding, “It seems credibility has declined this year due to overlapping issues involving JR Global REIT and the Joongang Group.”

Han Shin Rating scored 3.55 in the category of “proactive opinion provision,” which refers to providing opinions in advance regarding changes in a company’s credit risk. Satisfaction with rating reports stood at 3.79 points, while efforts to improve quality reached only 3.66 points. It is particularly disappointing that, unlike Han Ki-pyeong and Na Shin-pyeong—which shared first and second place in each category, including rating reliability, proactive opinion provision, satisfaction with rating reports, and quality improvement efforts—Han Shin-pyeong ranked last in all categories.

It is particularly painful that Han Shin Rating’s upward trend—which had continued for three consecutive years following the Legoland incident—has come to a halt. In particular, there are criticisms that Han Shin Rating’s credit risk warning regarding SLL Joongang, an affiliate of the Joongang Group, came later than that of its competitors. While Han Ki-pyeong changed SLL Joongang’s rating outlook to “negative” in June of last year, Han Shin-pyeong did not take the same action until April of this year—approximately nine and a half months later. Subsequently, on June 9, the credit rating was BBB-, but by June 15, it had been downgraded to B—a five-notch downgrade in just six days.

Market participants’ low satisfaction with Han Shin Rating was also evident in a question asking which rating agency they use most frequently. Out of a total of 197 respondents, 51 said they use Han Shin Rating most often—the lowest number among the three agencies, including Han Ki Rating (68) and Na Shin Rating (59).

Some respondents also pointed out Han Shin Rating’s “pro-business” bias. One survey respondent stated, “Han Shin Rating’s credit ratings seem somewhat business-friendly,” adding, “We have also observed instances where ratings (and outlooks) are adjusted quickly when upgraded but slowly when downgraded.” Another respondent also pointed out, “Han Shin Rating easily changes triggers to suit the issuer’s conditions.”

Another SRE advisory committee member pointed out, “Han Shin Rating seems to have developed a negative image of being biased toward corporations because it delays downgrades for large conglomerates—for example, it was the last to lower LG Chem’s rating during a rating split.”

[This article is excerpted from the 37th SRE (Survey of Credit Ratings by Edaily) booklet produced by Edaily.]

Economy

Corporation

IT·Science

Economy

[37th SRE][Survey] NICE Credit Rating, “One Step Ahead,” Ranks Second in Trustworthiness for the First Time in Three Years

NICE Credit Rating (NICE) ranked second in the credit rating reliability category of the 37th Edaily Survey of Credit Rating Experts (SRE). It was the only one of the three major credit rating agencie…
2026-11-17 08:35:04

Corporation

HYUNDAIDEPARTMENTSTORECO.,LTD to Pick Up Foreign VIPs at the Airport… Launches Exclusive Membership Program

HYUNDAIDEPARTMENTSTORECO.,LTD(069960)is introducing a chauffeur service that provides transportation from the airport to department stores for foreign VIP customers. As the purchasing power and visit …
2026-11-17 09:05:59

IT·Science

Innotena Reports Third-Quarter Revenue of 7.96 Billion Won… Achieves Best Quarterly Results This Year

AX specialist company MOCOMSYS(333050)(CEOs Kim In-soo and Yoon Young-ho) announced on the 17th that it recorded sales of 7.96 billion won in the third quarter of 2026, achieving its best quarterly pe…
2026-11-17 09:00:07